Friday, December 24, 2010

Responding to Christmas

The true way to respond to God's promises and actions in the birth of Christ is faith, believing what God has said and done. The major characters in the story took God at his word and acted accordingly. Mary believed the angelic message to her and submitted herself to God. Joseph also believed the angelic message to him and took Mary as his wife. The shepherds believed the angelic message and went to Bethlehem, praising God. Believing God is the hallmark of the people of God, beginning with Abraham who believed God and it was counted to him as righteousness.

Thursday, December 16, 2010

Time for WTS to write it's own history?

A while back I suggested to Pete Lillback, President of WTS/Philadelphia, that maybe it was time for the seminary to write it's history. George Marsden had written the history of Fuller seminary by then (and Fuller is much younger than WTS) and it seemed that WTS, as the older institution should be the subject of a good, scholarly history, too. Pete had reasons for that not happening, but I think it is time for that to happen. The reason? Everyone else is writing that history. In the recent festschrift for Bob Godfrey, D.G. Hart addresses developments at Westminster in the 1970s that he believes show a weakening of the original resolve at the seminary to stand for the orthodox faith. John Yeo, from Reformed Theological Seminary, has published his doctoral dissertation on the history and trajectory of the OT faculty at Westminster. Mark Karlberg has written on what he believes is the defection of the seminary from teaching justification by faith alone in favor of justification by covenant faithfulness.

With all these critical analyses of the seminary, maybe it is time for Westminster in Philadelphia to tell its own story.

Sunday, March 28, 2010

TEC A Prophetic Church? No way.

Reading the introduction to the Rev. Dr. Ashley Null's lecture on the 39 Articles and Reformation Anglicanism had me thinking about what it means to be a prophetic church (as the Episcopal Church is trying to be).

According to Scripture, prophets:
  • spoke the word of the Lord as it came from God.
  • prosecuted God's covenant lawsuit against Israel.
  • called the people of God to repentance.

Based on these 3 functions of prophets, the Episcopal Church is in no way acting prophetically when it speaks on matters of sex and morality. The Church rather is a false prophet, because it leads the people of God away from Him. The only biblically prophetic voice in TEC today comes from those who are conservative and traditional in their theology. They hold to a high view of Scripture as the Word of God. They denounce the sins of the Presiding Bishop and the House of Bishops. They call them and the rest of the Church to repentance.

The Daily Office readings from March 26 speak to the hardness of heart of God's people. I believe that the leadership of TEC has hardened their hearts. It is possible that just as God hardened the heart of Pharoah, God has hardened the hearts of the PB and most of the bishops. If so, that could mean that judgment is coming on the Church. Perhaps it has already come in the form of divisions and the scorn of the rest of the Anglican world. Like Pharoah, our leaders are stuck in their sins and there they may die. There is yet time to repent.

Friday, February 19, 2010

Dual Citizens

In his book, Dual Citizens, pastor Jason Stellman attempts to set forth his understanding of how the Bible describes what is known in Reformed and other circles as how believers are to live during the period of the “already/not yet.” This refers to the period between Christ’s first and second comings. Herman Ridderbos is one of the best known presenters of this idea, which he has done in his books The Coming of the Kingdom and Paul: An Outline of his Theology. According to Ridderbos (and others), Jesus’ birth, life, death and resurrection inaugurated the presence of God’s kingdom. Believers in Jesus receive the benefits of that kingdom: forgiveness, release from sin, new life and hope. Beyond that, this concept means that God’s rule has already begun in the life of Jesus. This is the “already.” The “not yet” refers to the future consummation of that kingdom.
Pastor Stellman’s purpose in his book is to develop the implications of the already/not yet for Christian life. This is a worthy task. It deals with the essence of our lives as we await Christ’s return. Having read the book, I have some concerns about his underlying presuppositions and how he constructs his approach. My concerns are with his separation of worship and life (what he calls cult and culture), his understanding of covenant theology and his caricatures of evangelical and Christian spiritual disciplines.
Since his separation of worship and life is based on his understanding of God’s covenant(s), I will begin there. An essential element of a Reformed understanding of God’s covenants is their unity. The various covenants are part of God’s overall covenantal approach and dealing with people in general and his people in particular. O. Palmer Robertson, in his Christ of the Covenants, devotes a whole chapter to the unity of God’s covenants, particularly the covenants with Noah, Abraham, Moses and David. These covenants build on the one before them and culminate in the New Covenant inaugurated by Jesus. This Reformed understanding is contrasted with a dispensational view which does not see the covenants as a unity and posits a difference between Israel and the Church.
Pastor Stellman’s approach to the covenants seems to be more dispensational than Reformed. I say this because he posits the need for a specific geographic location as important to how God’s covenants impact the way God’s people live. Under the covenants with Adam and Moses, God had initiated a theocracy which governed every aspect of life, including cult and culture. In regard to the covenant with Moses, it was especially in effect as long as Israel was in the land given them by God. When Israel was in exile in Babylon, the stipulations of the covenant governing Israel’s relationships with others did not apply. Once Israel returned to the land under Ezra and Nehemiah, all the stipulations of the covenant were once again in effect.
In regard to the conduct of believers during the period between Christ’s first and second comings, Pastor Stellman asserts that the church, like Israel in Babylon, is in exile. In this exilic state, it is possible to separate worship from the rest of life. He specifically rejects John Frame’s assertion that it is “difficult to separate “life” from “worship” in a biblical framework.” As Pastor Stellman writes, when they [God’s people] are exiles and pilgrims, they are called to separate themselves only religiously, not culturally.” This approach seems problematical. It seems to undercut the unity of the covenants. It also seems contrary to the realities of the New Covenant and Christ’s Lordship.
Under the New Covenant, the Church is called “a chosen people, a royal priesthood, a holy nation, a people belonging to God…” (I Peter 2:9 NIV). Paul says in Philippians 4:20, “our citizenship is in heaven…” He also tells us in Romans 12:2 to not be conformed to the world. Peter gives the same advice in I Peter 2:11-12.
The Church’s designation as a holy people and nation relates the Church to Israel. Yet, the Church is not in exile. The Church’s presence in the world is not punishment for disobedience, but for the purpose of declaring the glory of the one who brought them from darkness to life. Under the New Covenant, the church has no specific dedicated piece of land like Israel did in Canaan. All the earth belongs to the Lord (Ps. 24). Under the New Covenant, the possession of a specific piece of geography is not essential to the covenant since all the earth is the Lord’s. Thus, Pastor Stellman’s view of a separation between worship and life is without foundation. Christians are in the world to witness and they are called to be salt and light, separate from and not conforming to the world around them.
In this regard, Christians come in contact with the world around them. Like Israel, there are restrictions on how the Church interacts with the world. Christians are not to marry outside the faith (I Cor. 7:39). Believers are not to be yoked with unbelievers (2 Cor. 8:14-18). Christians are not to take each other to court (I Cor. 6). Christians were to take responsibility for each other, especially widows, orphans and any one else in need.
His book is clear about the differences between the church and the world and he makes some valuable evaluations of how the church operates in American culture. Christians in the United States must be open to suffering, be less demanding of prestige and power. Yet, in his evaluation of American evangelicalism, Pastor Stellman caricatures some spiritual disciplines that many American Christians, including this writer, find meaningful. These disciplines include a daily quiet time, listening to Christian music and retreats. He refers to these as “extra-canonical sacraments,” and hints that they are a gnostic form of spirituality (a charge that Mike Horton makes in Christless Christianity). He also implies that these practices stand in contrast to Reformed confessional understandings of Christian living, though without referring to specific confessional content. This Reformed confessional understanding centers on the local congregation where God’s Word is preached each Sunday.
Here he sets up a false dichotomy, and shows some personal bias toward American evangelicals. According to him (in Chapter 7), American evangelicals would rather practice personal individual piety than attend a local church where the Word of God is preached. Perhaps that is true in some cases, but the reality is that evangelical Christians probably attend church more than they practice individual disciplines. For me (and no doubt for many others) the discipline of a daily quiet time does not rule out attendance at a local congregation. The two practices complement each other. The practice of a daily quiet time is not to receive special revelation (as in Gnosticism) to “read, mark, learn and inwardly digest” the Scriptures, to meditate on them and to engage in daily prayer. Corporate worship is important, but it does not rule out individual worship.
In another area, he is critical of the desire of evangelicals for application in the sermons they hear. This, he says, is a desire for law not gospel. I wonder what he does with the letters of the Apostle Paul. Many of Paul’s letters can be divided into two parts: the indicative (what God has done in Christ) and the imperative (the application of the indicative). Much evangelical preaching probably is more application or “practical” and less oriented toward declaring what God has done in Christ. But the desire for application means that Christians take seriously what it means to be a Christian and how we live out our faith in the world. This would be similar to those aspects of the Law that defined how Israel was to live in a pagan environment. Given the state of American Christianity, as evangelicals like Ron Side and Jim Wallis have pointed out, American Christians need more application to know how to live as God’s holy people in the midst of a pagan society.
American Christians (as do all Christians) live as dual citizens of two worlds. Yet the Head of the Church is the Lord of the nations. Our allegiance is to one Lord. But, as Paul says in Philippians 4:20, our citizenship is in heaven. It is from the consummation of the kingdom that we are exiles and pilgrims. It is the values of God’s kingdom that are to guide us during our pilgrimage.

Tuesday, January 19, 2010

Scripture in the Second London Confession

Some have asked about access to my Th.M. thesis from Westminster Theological Seminary on the Second London Confession of Faith. While the thesis has not been published, I am posting an essay I wrote about the doctrine of Scripture in the confession.

Baptists believe that the Bible is supreme in all matters of faith and life. For this reason they have been among the strongest defenders of the inerrancy and infallibility of the Bible. They did this first in 1677 in the opening words of the Second London Baptist Confession of Faith: “The Holy Scripture is the only sufficient, certain, and infallible rule of all saving Knowledge, Faith, and Obedience…”[1] This statement is notable for two reasons. It is the first confessional statement of the infallibility of the Bible; and it is an addition to what is otherwise the nearly identical text of the same chapter in the Westminster Confession of Faith upon which the Second London Confession is based. Why did the Baptists address the infallibility of the Bible?
Certainly it is not because the Westminster Divines or the Puritans believed the Bible to be fallible. Leland Ryken points to the views of William Ames and John Owen (among others) who believed in the infallibility of the Bible.[2] The statement probably shows the influence of Benjamin Keach (1640-1704), a Particular Baptist pastor in London, who claimed infallibility for Scripture. “That the scripture, or book called the Bible, is of divine original, inspired by the Spirit of God, and therefore of infallible truth and authority appears.”[3] Again, “…this God, out of his great love and goodness, hath given us one sure, and infallible rule of faith and practice, viz. the Holy Scriptures. The reason for addressing the infallibility of the Bible is more likely due to changes in attitudes toward the Bible in the later half of the 1600s. This essay will identify three such changes presented by radical religious groups, Rationalism and biblical criticism. The radical groups generally denied the divine origin of Scripture and denied its truthfulness. Rationalism superseded the content of Scripture. Biblical criticism questioned the nature and teaching of Scripture. All denied the infallibility of Holy Scripture.


The Bible in Seventeenth Century England
The Bible was popular in England in the early 1600s. It was “omnipresent in houses,” e.g., in homes and alehouses, where biblical texts and stories adorned the walls. People opened the Bible at random for divine guidance. All the parties to political discussions used the Bible to justify their positions. Copies of the Scriptures in the Authorized Version and the Geneva Bible were bought and read. As a result, “almost everybody in the sixteenth century and most in the seventeenth accepted that the Bible was the authoritative source of all wisdom…”[4] C. John Sommerville found that Scripture was an often mentioned source of religious authority.[5]
The situation changed in the latter years of the seventeenth century. David Katz wrote, “If it is true that the first half of the seventeenth century was the high-water mark of bibliolatry in England, it follows that from that point on the waters had to recede…The most ardent supporters of sola scriptura were so convinced of the impregnability of biblical authority that they fearlessly investigated every conceivable aspect of Scripture, and were amazed to discover that their examinations…caused irreparable cracks in the entire edifice.”[6] One of the “irreparable cracks” was doubts about the infallibility of Scripture.
Challenges to Holy Scripture
Radical Religion
Radical religious groups viewed the Bible as a human work and thus not trustworthy in religious matters and set up a dichotomy between the Spirit and Scripture. Gerrard Winstanley (1609?-1660?), a Digger, believed that the Virgin Birth, the resurrection of Jesus, and the story of the Fall were allegories.[7] He held that the "Law and Testimony to which I must have recourse for my comfort, is not the words or writings of other men without me; But the spirit of the Father in me, teaching me to know him by experience…this is the Law and the Testimony.”[8] The Scriptures “were not his own words [God’s] but those of men with similar experience.”[9]
Samuel Fisher (1605-1665), a Presbyterian turned Baptist turned Quaker, offered similar arguments. In his analysis of Scripture, The Rustics Alarm to the Rabbies, Fisher challenged the reliability of the text of Scripture, questioned the source of divine authority of the present canon because the transcribers made errors in their work, and believed that Scripture is “a bulk of heterogeneous writings, compiled together by men taking what they could find of the several sorts of writings that are therein, and…crowding them into a canon, or standard for the trial of all spirits, doctrines, truth; and by them alone.”[10]
In 1675, Robert Barclay, a Quaker, published and presented to King Charles II, An Apology for the True Christian Divinity, written to “present the world with a brief, but true account of this people's principles [the Quakers], in short some theological propositions.”[11] Proposition III explains the Quaker understanding of Scripture. Scripture proceeds from “the revelations of the Spirit of God to the saints” and contains
“1. A faithful historical account of the actings of
God’s people in divers ages….
2. A prophetical account of several things, whereof
some are already past, and some yet to come.
3. A full and ample account of all the chief principles
of the doctrine of Christ….”[12]
Moreover, Scripture is not the chief rule of faith and practice for two reasons. First, it is “only a declaration of the fountain, and not the fountain itself.” It is “a secondary rule, subordinate to the Spirit.”[13] Because the Spirit is the only way that we can know God and be led into all truth, it is the primary rule of faith and life. Second, it is not complete and does not address every conceivable situation. Barclay wrote,
That which is given to Christians for a rule and
guide, must needs be so full, that it may clearly
and distinctly guide and order them in all things
and occurrences that may fall out. But, in that
there are numberless things, with regard to
their circumstances, which particular Christians
may be concerned in, for which there can be no
particular rule had in the scriptures. Therefore,
the scriptures cannot be a rule to them.[14]
The radical challenge to Scripture reduced it to a “mirror” for living saints to learn from the experiences of past saints, as well as an incomplete and textually untrustworthy collection of writings.
Rationalism
An Anglican cleric declared in 1667 “the universal disposition of this Age is bent upon a rational religion,” meant “to replace the weight of dusty authorities with the simple process, accessible to all, of logical argument from clear and distinct ideas to the most complex and yet certain knowledge.”[15] Reason was "the means by which certainty is attained, through the assent of the mind to evidence proposed to it."[16] It referred to "the use of rational processes in perceiving facts and evaluating arguments."[17] Richard Hooker wrote, "Those Laws [of nature] are investigable by Reason, without the help of Revelation supernatural and divine."[18]
Reason had three roles in seventeenth century English theology. First, it guarded against religious anarchy brought on by “enthusiasm” and individual interpretation of Scripture.[19] The Anglican theologian William Chillingworth argued that reason was the guide to understanding the elements of Christianity that are essential for salvation.[20] Thomas Hobbes wrote, "God declareth his laws...by the dictates of natural reason...."[21]
Second, reason made logical arguments for God’s existence and the truthfulness of Christian belief to demonstrate Christianity’s rationality, reasonableness and believability. Edward Fowler, Bishop of Gloucester, claimed that we believe the Bible because it is God’s word, but we believe God “upon the proposition of reason that ‘God cannot lie.” Joseph Glanville held that reason “proves some main and fundamental articles of faith, and defends all, by proving the authority of Holy Scripture.”[22]
Third, reason judged the content of Scripture and the truthfulness of Christian belief on the grounds that “reason has jurisdiction over faith, that it has the power to examine it, to reject or accept it strictly according to evidence.”[23] The Anglican minister Robert South argued in a sermon, "My reason must prove to me that it [something supposedly revealed by God] is revealed." For South, this means "Reason is that into which all Religion is at last resolved.”[24] Frederick Beiser has concluded that this use of reason transformed Protestantism, for it made reason the “ultimate, if unconfessed and implicit, rule of faith.”[25]
The rationalists believed that Scripture could not stand by itself. The idea of Scripture as the self-verifying rule of faith was not able to “convince the skeptic, the enthusiast, and the Roman Catholic, who denied the ultimate authority of Scripture.”[26] As an example of this view, Hooker wrote
But it is not the word of God which doth or
possibly can assure us, that we do well to
think it his word. For if any one book of
Scripture did give testimony to all, yet still
that Scripture which giveth credit to the rest
would require another Scripture to give credit
unto it…[27]
If radical religion replaced Scripture with the Spirit, rational religion replaced Scripture with the authority of human reason.
Biblical Criticism
Another challenge came from the rising field of biblical criticism as represented by Benedict Spinoza. Spinoza criticized those who "by their laying down beforehand as a foundation for the study and true interpretation of Scripture, the principle that it is in every passage true and divine."[28] In his view, such a position should only be reached after careful "scrutiny and thorough comprehension of the Sacred Books."[29] Spinoza claims to have done that, concluding, "The authority of the prophets has weight only in matters of morality, and that their speculative doctrines affect us little."[30]
Spinoza also criticized those who paid "homage to the Books of the Bible, rather than to the Word of God," which has not been revealed as a certain number of books. The Word of God is more than the written works of the Bible, though they, too, may be called the Word of God. They are God's Word only as they affect religion, and to that extent they are not "faulty, tampered with, nor corrupt."[31] Yet, the Bible is fallible because "God adapted revelations to the understanding and opinions of the prophets...It therefore follows that we must by no means go to the prophets for knowledge, either of natural or spiritual phenomena."[32] He concludes that we are only bound to believe "the object and substance of the revelation" in the writings of the prophets, and believe whatever we want regarding the details. Regarding the details, Spinoza cataloged all the errors in the genealogies, the history, and even the prophecies. All the believer must do is to believe the pure and uncorrupted Word of God ("obedience to God in singleness of heart, and in the practice of justice and charity..."). Spinoza argues, though, that Scripture is "sacred and Divine," as he defines such terms. "A thing is called sacred and Divine when it is designed for promoting piety, and continues sacred so long as it is religiously used: if the users cease to be pious, the thing ceases to be sacred...."[33] Sacredness is only a relative state. "Thus Scripture is sacred, and its words Divine so long as it stirs mankind to devotion toward God: but if it be utterly neglected, as it formerly was by the Jews, it becomes nothing but paper and ink, and is left to be desecrated or corrupted...."[34]
Questions of Authority
At the heart of these challenges was the question of authority. As Beiser notes, “The central concern of the infallibility controversy…was epistemological. What justifies the authority of the Church? What is the final rule of faith: Scripture, tradition, reason, or the pope?”[35] Radicals and rationalists believed that Scripture could be inspired of God, but was not infallible. Roman Catholics agreed with them about the inspiration of Scripture, but held that the pope, as an interpreter of Scripture, was infallible. Roman Catholic apologists argued against Scripture as a sufficient rule of faith on the basis of obscure passages in Scripture and contradictory interpretations of Scripture.[36] Radicals and rationalists made this objection, too. For radicals, this is made the Spirit supreme. For rationalists, only Reason could overcome such contradictory interpretations. For the Roman Catholics, only the pope can be an infallible interpreter of Scripture.[37]
The Anglicans, for their part, questioned the very notion of infallibility in religious matters, partly to rebut Catholic claims of infallibility, and partly because infallibility was not considered possible. Jeremy Taylor, for example, held "that there could be no infallible guide in religious matters."[38] William Chillingworth argued in The Religion of Protestants a Safe Way to Salvation that infallible knowledge in religion was unnecessary since knowledge in that arena was based on our senses and reliable witnesses. Therefore, we already have "moral certainty" that was at the level of conviction. Certain knowledge was only possible in mathematics and metaphysics, which were different from religion.[39] Only mathematical proofs could lead to absolute or infallible certainty. The testimony of other people had only a moral certainty. Scripture only had moral certainty since our evidence of its truth depends on the testimony of others.[40]
At the heart of this skepticism was the questioning of authority based on the Protestant idea of the liberty of the individual conscience. Infallibility was irrelevant since the "final source of intellectual authority is only the fallible judgment of individual reason," and dogmatism was to be avoided.[41]
The Confession Affirms Infallibility
It is in the contexts of radical religion, skepticism, and discussions of infallibility that we may begin to understand why the drafters of the Second London Baptist Confession of Faith addressed the sufficiency, certainty and infallibility of Scripture. Against the subjectivity of reason or the Inner Light or the Holy Spirit as the primary religious authority, the Baptist confession asserts that Holy Scripture is the infallible rule of "saving Knowledge, Faith, and Obedience". Against views that reduced Scripture to "an historical account" (Barclay and the Quakers) or a repository of rational religion, the opening sentence of the 1677 confession asserts "Holy Scripture is the only...rule of all Saving Knowledge, Faith, and Obedience." Against charges that Scripture is insufficient as an authoritative religious resource, the confession asserts the sufficiency and infallibility of Scripture for the life of the church and the Christian.
Having asserted the sufficiency of Scripture, the Confession explained the basis for the assertion: “The Authority of the Holy Scripture for which it ought to be believed dependeth…wholly upon God (who is truth itself) the Author thereof; therefore it is to be received because it is the Word of God” (S.L.C. I.4). Moreover, “our full persuasion, and assurance of the infallible truth, and divine authority thereof, is from the inward work of the Holy Spirit bearing witness by and with the Word in our Hearts” (S.L.C. I.5).
In the context of the various sources of knowing God's will, the confession's position on the sufficiency, certainty and infallibility of Scripture is an act of faith (and not the result of reason) as defined in Chapter XIV.1-2 of the confession. Saving faith "is the work of the Spirit of Christ" in the hearts of the Elect, enabling them to believe to be true "whatsoever is revealed in the Word, for the Authority of God himself."
In Chapter 1.10, the drafters of the Second London Baptist Confession declared that "the supreme[e] judge" of all religious controversies "can be no other but the Holy Scripture delivered by the Spirit, into which Scripture so delivered, our faith is finally resolved." Because Holy Scripture has been inspired by the Holy Spirit, the Scriptures alone are the infallible judge of all controversies. For the Baptists, Scripture is the final word.
In the seventeenth century discussions of religious authority, there were several options: Scripture and reason; Scripture and natural theology; the Inner Light; reason alone; Scripture and papal authority; and Scripture alone. While recognizing the place of natural revelation in revealing God's attributes, the London Baptists recognized the insufficiency of natural revelation and acknowledged "the Holy Scripture to be most necessary" (I.1). By implication in I.4-5 (essentially copied from the Westminster Confession), the Baptists repudiated the role of reason as a means to undergird the authority of Scripture. "The Authority of the Holy Scripture for which it ought to be believed dependeth not upon the testimony of any man, or Church, but wholly upon God." "...our full persuasion, and assurance of the infallible truth, and divine authority thereof, is from the inward work of the Holy Spirit...." In I.6 the confession rejects any extra-biblical sources (the Inner Light, reason, nature) for the "whole Councel of God." The confession recognizes the need for the work of the Holy Spirit to enable anyone to understand Scripture. It even recognizes the "light of nature" to order life in the Church, though the confession does not explain how this is so. Further, the confession recognizes that not all things in Scripture are plain and understandable. The only infallible rule of interpretation of Scripture is Scripture itself.
While repudiating reason, nature and the Spirit as adjuncts to, or replacements of, Scripture as a source of religious authority, the confession offers a mediating way among all these options. By placing Scripture at the center, the confession seeks to avoid the subjectivity of Reason or the Inner Light. Putting Scripture in the center allows the confession to recognize the roles of the Holy Spirit and the light of nature in the life of the church. The Spirit gives the believer confidence in Scripture and its contents, as well as "saving understanding of such things as are revealed in the Word" (I.6). On the other hand, the "light of nature" and "Christian prudence" may be used to order some circumstances. However, neither the Spirit nor the "light of nature" nor prudence operate independently of Scripture. Scripture is the context in which both operate.
Finally, the Second London Confession recognizes that some passages and doctrines are not easy to understand. Yet, "those things which are necessary to be known, believed, and observed for Salvation are so clearly propounded, and opened in some place of Scripture or other" that anyone "in a due use of ordinary means" may reach an understanding of them. The "ordinary means" may include reason as well as common sense. What ever they are, the confession affirms the perspicuity of Scripture. Scripture remains at the center, "the sufficient, certain, and infallible rule."
The Legacy of the Confession
The confession’s use of “infallible” to describe Holy Scripture was a tiny voice in the midst of much larger discussions and had no discernable impact on the direction of those discussions. Indeed, no subsequent Baptist confession (aside from the Philadelphia Confession of 1742 which was essentially the 1677 confession with two additional chapters) described Scripture as infallible until the early 1800s.[42] The New Hampshire Confession of 1833 did not use the term infallible, but noted “the Holy Bible…has God for its author…and truth without any mixture of error, for its matter.”[43] Free Will Baptists, The American Baptist Association, and the North American Baptist Association all have confessed the infallibility of Scripture.[44]
In the twentieth century, “the infallible rule of faith and practice” became a common phrase in statements of faith adopted by evangelical congregations, seminaries, and other Christian organizations.[45] Belief in the infallibility of Scripture (and the inerrancy of Scripture) became an evangelical distinction. Though there is no causal relationship between the Second London Confession and these confessions of faith, many of the same issues that led the Particular Baptists in 1677 to describe the Bible as infallible still exist in the twentieth and twenty-first centuries. Biblical criticism, in the form of the Jesus Seminar, presents new challenges to the integrity of the texts of Scripture.[46] Inter-religious dialogue and religious pluralism challenges the authority of Scripture alone for the life of the church and for its message.[47]
Conclusion
In the absence of any explicit statements by the writers of the Second London Confessionregarding the infallibility of Scripture, this essay has tried to place its use in the context of discussions about Scripture in seventeenth century English church life. By ascribing infallibility to Holy Scripture, the Baptists disassociated themselves from the Catholic view that the pope is infallible, and as well as those who placed the Spirit or their own judgment over the authority of Holy Scripture. Where the truthfulness of Scripture was challenged, the Baptists asserted the certainty and infallibility of Scripture. Scripture was the basis for understanding God’s will and God’s world.
[1] Second London Confession of Faith (hereinafter S.L.C.) I.1. The text of the Confession used here is found in William L. Lumpkin, Baptist Confessions of Faith, Rev. ed. (Valley Forge, PA: Judson Press, 1969), 235-295.
[2] Leland Ryken, Worldly Saints: The Puritans as they Really Were (Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1990), 141.
[3] Benjamin Keach, Tropologia: A Key to Open Scripture Metaphors (London: William Hill Collingridge City Press, 1858), ix.
[4] Christopher Hill, “The Bible in Seventeenth-Century English Politics,” The Tanner Lectures on Human Values, 90, (18 December 2005).
[5] C. John Sommerville, Popular Religion in Restoration England (Gainesville, Flor.: University Presses of Florida, 1977), 62.
[6] David S. Katz, God’s Last Words: Reading the English Bible from the Reformation to Fundamentalism (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2004), 74..
[7] Christopher Hill, The World Turned Upside Down (Middlesex, England: Penguin Books, 1975), 142-145.
[8] Gerrard Winstanley, “Saints Paradice,” quoted in Donald R. Sutherland, “The Religion of Gerrard Winstanley and Digger Communism,” Essays in History 33 (1991), <http://etext.lib.virginia.edu/journals/EH/EH33/suther33.html> (15 March 2005).
[9] Sutherland, “The Religion of Gerrard Winstanley and Digger Communism.”

[10] Samuel Fisher, quoted in Christopher Hill, The World Turned Upside Down, 266-267.

[11] Robert Barclay, An Apology for a True Christian Divinity, 6th ed. (London: T. Sowle Raylton, 1736), [7].
[12] Barclay, 67.
[13] Barclay, 71.

[14] Barclay, 74.

[15] John Spurr, “’Rational Religion’ in Restoration England,” Journal of the History of Ideas 49, no. 4 (October-December 1988): 563.
[16] Martin I.J. Griffin, Richard Henry Popkin, and Lila Freeman, Latitudinarianism in the Seventeenth-Century Church of England (Leiden: E.J. Brill, 1992), 61.
[17] Alan C. Clifford, Atonement and Justification: English Evangelical Theology, 1640-1790 (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1990), 43; quoted in W. M. Spellman, The Latitudinarians in the Church of England, 1660-1700 (Athens, GA: University of Georgia Press), 4.
[18] Richard Hooker, Of the Laws of Ecclesiastical Polity I.8.8., (22 July 2005).
[19] Spurr, “Rational Religion”, p. 568. Enthusiast was a term applied to the Puritans as well as Quakers, Ranters and similar groups.
[20] Spellman, 21.

[21] Thomas Hobbes, Leviathan, ed. and with introduction and notes by Edwin Curley (Indianapolis: Hackett Publishing, 1994), II.xxxi.[3]. Divine revelation and the voice of man were two other ways God communicated his laws.
[22] Griffin, 38.

[23] Frederick C. Beiser, The Sovereignty of Reason: the Defense of Rationality in the Early English Enlightenment (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1996), 15.
[24] Robert South, Sermons, quoted in Spurr, "Rational Religion," 576.

[25] Beiser, 11.

[26] Beiser, 11.

[27] Hooker, II.4.2.

[28] Benedict de Spinoza, A Theologico-Politico Treatise, trans. R.H.M. Elwes (New York: Dover Publications, 1951), 8.
[29] Spinoza, 8.
[30] Spinoza, 8.

[31] Spinoza, 9, 172.

[32] Spinoza, 40.

[33] Spinoza, 167.

[34] Spinoza, 168.

[35] Beiser, 105.

[36] Griffin, 55-56.

[37] Griffin, 109-110.

[38] Jeremy Taylor, A Discourse of the Liberty of Prophecying quoted in Spellman, 24.
[39] Spellman, 21.

[40] Spurr, 575-576.

[41] Beiser, 111.

[42] Lumpkin, “Terms of Union Between the Elkhorn and South Kentucky, or Separate, Associations,” 359.
[43] Lumpkin, 362.

[44] Lumpkin, 369, 378, 380.

[45] Examples are Latin America Mission, “Statement of Faith,” <http://www.lam.org/about/statement_of_faith.php?> (12 July 2006); The Lausanne Covenant <http://www.lausane.org> (12 July 2006); Asbury Theological Seminary, “Statement of Faith,” <http://www.ats.wilmore.ky.us/about/faith.htm> (12 July 2006).
[46] The Jesus Seminar <http://www.westarinstitute.org/Jesus_Seminar/jesus_seminar.html> (13 July 2006).
[47] An example of this trend may be seen in Sarah J. Melcher, “’Genuine Pluralism’ and Reformed Christology,” CrossCurrents 54, no. 4 (Winter 2005): 6-17.

Thursday, November 26, 2009

Christless Christianity, part 3

The final comments about Horton's Christless Christianity have to do with the charge of Gnosticism in American Christianity and Horton's use of secondary sources to argue his position in the book.

I have a hard time identifying American Christianity with the Gnostics of the early church era. I am not convinced by his arguments that this is true. To make this argument, Horton depends on the work of Harold Bloom, especially his work The American Religion. Here, Bloom sees Gnostics under every rock. His own Gnosticism becomes the lens through which he interprets American Christianity. However, Bloom's work has been criticized by Martin Marty and Alfred Kazin. They say that the charge of Gnosticism might stick if applied only to non-Christian American religion and the search for spirituality. Bloom, however, tries to make it stick to Christianity in the United States. The Gnosticism he sees appears in the private aspects of Protestantism. He especially takes a shot at the Baptist idea of "soul competency." As defined by Baptists, this means "the God-given freedom and ability of persons to know and respond to God’s will. Baptists believe that God gives people competency--that is ability--to make choices. Human beings are not puppets or machines." There is nothing particulary Gnostic about this.

It seems that Horton has used Bloom's work and the work of Harold Lee (who agrees with Bloom) rather uncritically. It is this uncritical use of secondary sources which bothers me about his book. Rather than do his own investigation of the use and place of Christ in American preaching, he relies on the work of other people, not to illustrate his own research, but in place of it.

Horton's book would have been better if he concentrated on Joel Osteen and the prosperity gospel movement and done so with his own analysis.

Monday, November 9, 2009

Christless Christianity, Part 2

In chapter 3 of Christless Christianity, Mike Horton analyzes the ministry of Joel Osteen and others like him. This is one of the most passionate chapters in the book. Osteen's ministry becomes the paradigm to analyze popular religion in the United States. Horton's analysis of Osteen can be summarized in the phrase facere quod in se est (do your best) from medieval theology. Osteen even seems to think that God will "make it up" in regard to difference between God's expectations and our efforts. Osteen may not be a theologian, but he seems to have grasped the essentials of medieval Christian theology.

A curious aspect of Horton's analysis is his statement (which he admits sounds heretical), "it is probably worth telling Americans that you don't need Jesus to have better families, finances, health, or even morality." I think Horton is saying that this is the gist of most American preaching. Christians as well as most Americans do not need to believe in Jesus to have all the good things of life. However, for those of us who live in the already/not yet period between the resurrection and Christ's return, having Jesus is no guarantee of any of these blessings. Indeed, following Christ can mean family divisions, poverty, illness and death.

Turning to chapter 4 (How we turn good news into good advice), Horton uses the law-gospel distinction to analyze modern religion. His discussion raises a couple questions. One concerns his assertion that we are not to live the gospel, but only believe it. He resists the idea of living the gospel because he thinks that makes it a message about us. I think Paul would disagree. He wrote in 2 Corinthians 3:2, "You yourselves are our letter of recommendation, written on our hearts, to be known and read by all. And you show that you are a letter from Christ, delievered by us, written not with ink, but with the Spirit of the living God, not on tablets of stone but on tablets of human hearts" (ESV). Paul seems to be saying that the Corinthians were living gospels because of the work of God's Spirit in them. Paul also wrote to the Ephesians, Therefore be imitators of God, as beloved children. And walk in love as Christ loved us and gave himself up for us, a fragrant offering and sacrifice to God" (5:1-2) (ESV). Again, Paul seems to say that imitating Christ is not law, but gospel. Paul gives practical advice, instruction and calls to discipleship which may be considered as gospel because they grow out of our justification and salvation in Christ.

A second question about law and gospel arises when Horton says we need "a fresh encounter with God's law in its full force." The question is this: did Jesus and Paul preach the law? It seems that the answer must be, No, because they preached the good news of the kingdom. It must be said that Peter and Paul, when addressing the Jews, spoke about the Jewish rejection of Jesus and the judgment that would follow if they did not repent and believe in Jesus. Jesus preached "repent and believe the good news." The problem with American preaching may be that pastors do not know how to preach the gospel because they do not know how to preach Christ from the OT, and they do not know how to ground behavior in the work of Christ. Whenever pastors give good advice, instruct their hearers in the teachings of the Bible and call them to discipleship, they need to ground all that in the work of Christ which people are called to believe.

It is finally in this chapter that Horton tells us what he means by "Christless Christianity." In his words it

does not mean religion or spirituality devoid of the words Jesus, Christ, Lord or even
Saviour. What it means is the way those names and titles are employed will be
removed from their specific location in an unfolding historical plot of human rebellion
and divine rescue and from such practices as baptism and communion.

If he had put this in the first chapter and organized the book around this definition, this work would be more clear, cogent and concise.

More to follow.

Saturday, November 7, 2009

Christless Christianity

The recent discussion in the blogosphere over John Frame's review of Michael Horton's book Christless Christianity (http://www.frame-poythress.org/frame_articles/2009Horton.htm) has led me to buy a copy of Professor Horton's book to read for myself. I finished the book a few days ago, but today is the first chance I've had to post my own comments. This entry will focus on Horton's book. I will evaluate John Frame's response in another post.

In general, I found the work to be uneven. Chapters 6 and 7 are well written and thought out. The arguments are clear, concise and cogent. The work of Christ is clearly spelled out in Chapter 6 and a call to faithfulness is well presented in Chapter 7.

The earlier chapters, however, seemed to me to have been written in a rush. There is a sense of passion in his arguments, which is not wrong in and of itself, but makes these chapters less well thought out than the closing chapters. I found myself making a number of comments about what he was saying. I will return to these chapters below.

Second, I think a better subtitle such as A Critique of Joel Osteen and the Prosperity Gospel would have been preferable. This is where the meat of Horton's argument is directed and would have saved him from Frame's criticism of painting with a broad brush.

Third, Horton is right in describing some parts of evangelicalism (to say nothing of liberalism) as vacuous. I have worshiped in some churches where the prayers and the sermon really said nothing useful. He is also correct in identifying a particular kind of American Christianity. In this regard, he could have strengthened his case by refering to the work of Mark Noll in his book America's God which clearly describes an American theology that has been shaped by American ideals. For instance, on page 54 Horton says, "It is not secular humanists but we ourselves who are secularizing the faith by transforming its odd message in some less jarring to the American psyche." This is precisely the point Noll makes in his work.

I will now review the first three chapters of Christless Christianity as well as chapter 5.

In chapter one, Horton describes what he means by Christless Christianity. It is that Christ is not preached in the apostolic sense. Instead, Jesus is a prop "for our own play." Sermons address issues like marriage, spiritual disciplines. Some of what Horton writes is similar to Ed Clowney's test of a Christian sermon: If a rabbi could preach that sermon, it wasn't Christian.

Yet, Horton's argument in chapter 1 is not totally convincing. He does not paint a clear picture of what he really means by a Christless Christianity. The closest he comes is his oft repeated phrase, "Do more, try harder." While this may be true, he says this is what he assumes "to be the regular diet in many churches across America..." (p. 17). He does not say at this point what grounds he has for that assumption. It is almost like he is setting up a straw man to knock down. As his discussions in the book later show, however, he is not setting up a straw man. If he had introduced some of that evidence in this first chapter, his arguments would be on firmer ground.

At the end of the chapter, Horton acknowledges that his judgments may be too sweeping or ill-informed. He further claims not to have any "particular wing, movement, person, or group" in mind. Further reading in the book reveals, however, that he does have particular persons in mind. Aside from that, he does make judgments that are too sweeping.

Chapter 2 is dedicated to naming the American captivity, which he calls "moralistic, therapeutic deism." Part of his arguments in this chapter are anecdotes, part based on the research of George Barna, Christian Smith, James Davison Hunter and other researchers, as well as magazine articles and even television dialogue. The closest Horton comes to dealing with primary sources is when he analyzes the preaching of Charles Finney. Yet, there is a difference between the Arminian, Semi-Pelagian preaching of Finney and the preaching recorded by Barna and others. He is right that some of Finney's preaching could be called moralistic, but it is a stretch to call it therapeutic and deistic.

Horton's sources in this chapter are one problem for me. Using secondary sources may be a time saving device, but in the age of the Internet, he could have searched for sermons online to evaluate and draw his own conclusions.

A second problem for me in this chapter is the structure. On page 48 he notes the work of Marcha Witten who analyzed a number of sermons regarding the prodigal son preached by Southern Baptist and PCUSA pastors. Yet, it is not until page 55 that he more or less begins to deal with the results of her work. The intervening pages are a side trip in which he again discusses the problem he sees with some parts of American Christianity. When he begins to discuss her findings, he does so uncritically. Witten found that the sermons treated God as the extravagent lover. Horton seems to accept this conclusion. Yet, is this not the point of the parable, especially as described by Tim Keller in his book The Prodigal God? Horton laments the absence of any need of a mediator or Christ's atoning work. He seems to have forgotten that this is a parable and must be understood as such. Witten found (and Horton accepts) that the preachers had a variety of things to say about the younger son and critiques the pastors for what they said and did not say. Some of their comments about the younger son are moralistic and perhaps do not take seriously enough his actions. But the parable is about God and is meant for the Pharisees. Neither Witten or Horton seem to get this.

More later.

Wednesday, October 21, 2009

Anglicans and Rome

For the life of me, I cannot understand why any Anglican/Episcopalian would accept the invitation of the Bishop of Rome to return to the Roman Catholic Church. Granted, the Catholic Church of today is not the church of the days of Henry VIII. Yet, Roman Catholic teaching on important articles of faith are at variance with the teachings of the 39 Articles and the English Reformers.

Those from the Anglican community who are open to the Bishop of Rome's invitation seem to do so for two reasons: Roman Catholic moral teaching which has not given in to the moral relativism found in the Episcopal Church; and to be seen to be ecumenical. However, they are overlooking fundamental differences between the two churches regarding the basics of salvation. The 39 Articles and the English reformers, e.g., Archbishop Cranmer, teach a decidedly Protestant and Reformed view of justification by faith. The Catholic Church continues to hold to unreformed views of justification.

The 39 Articles position on justification is clear:

XI. Of the Justification of Man.We are accounted righteous before God, only for the merit of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ by Faith, and not for our own works or deservings. Wherefore, that we are justified by Faith only, is a most wholesome Doctrine, and very full of comfort, as more largely is expressed in the Homily of Justification.

Compare this to the teaching of the Catechism of the Catholic Church of 1992:

1992 Justification has been merited for us by the Passion of Christ who offered himself on the cross as a living victim, holy and pleasing to God, and whose blood has become the instrument of atonement for the sins of all men. Justification is conferred in Baptism, the sacrament of faith. It conforms us to the righteousness of God, who makes us inwardly just by the power of his mercy. Its purpose is the glory of God and of Christ, and the gift of eternal life:[40] But now the righteousness of God has been manifested apart from law, although the law and the prophets bear witness to it, the righteousness of God through faith in Jesus Christ for all who believe. For there is no distinction: since all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God, they are justified by his grace as a gift, through the redemption which is in Christ Jesus, whom God put forward as an expiation by his blood, to be received by faith. This was to show God's righteousness, because in his divine forbearance he had passed over former sins; it was to prove at the present time that he himself is righteous and that he justifies him who has faith in Jesus.[41]

1990 Justification detaches man from sin which contradicts the love of God, and purifies his heart of sin. Justification follows upon God's merciful initiative of offering forgiveness. It reconciles man with God. It frees from the enslavement to sin, and it heals.

2008 The merit of man before God in the Christian life arises from the fact that God has freely chosen to associate man with the work of his grace. The fatherly action of God is first on his own initiative, and then follows man's free acting through his collaboration, so that the merit of good works is to be attributed in the first place to the grace of God, then to the faithful. Man's merit, moreover, itself is due to God, for his good actions proceed in Christ, from the predispositions and assistance given by the Holy Spirit.

2019 Justification includes the remission of sins, sanctification, and the renewal of the inner man.

While there are similarities between the two statements, but the Catholic statement puts more emphasis on human merit and action to the point of collaboration with God. The Catholic view of justification combines justification into one, rather than keeping them separate as reformation theology does.

For this and other reasons, Anglicans should be wary about returning to Rome. Rome has not reformed itself enough to warrant the return of anyone from Canterbury.

Tuesday, October 6, 2009

A Conservative Bible??

It is not enough to make god in our image. News on the Internet today heralds the planning of a "conservative" Bible, i.e., a Bible that reflects the language and concepts of political and economic conservatives. http://www.conservapedia.com/Conservative_Bible_Project claims that the Bible as translated now is too liberal. By liberal they mean:
  • a framework of liberal bias. This includes the presence of John 8:53ff (the woman taken in adultery), the inclusion of verses not found in the best manuscripts, socialism (as evidenced by terms like comrade) and questioning the use of "shrewdly" in regard to the dishonest manager in the Gospels.
  • not emasculated, a reference to the unisex of the NIV and other translations.
  • not dumbing down the language of Scripture in translations. They complain that the NIV is written for a 7th grade reading level. This begs the question of how difficult the language of Scripture should be. Since the NT was written in koine Greek, which was the common language of the people, it seems right to translate the NT into a language which its readers can understand. Martin Luther recognized this when he produced a Bible in German for common people to read.
  • using language that hides addictions. Their example here is "casting lots" instead of gambling. However, the Roman soldiers were not gambling when they cast lots for Jesus' clothing. Casting lots was a common practice in the ancient world and in the Bible.
  • not understanding the free market language of Jesus' parables. Jesus's parables were not economic lessons, but lessons about the kingdom of God.
  • being wordy.
  • not translating Word (logos) in John 1:1 by the word truth.

This project only makes sense as another way in which people reject the revelation of God. Rather than being challenged and transformed by God's inerrant and infallible Word, this project seeks to judge God's Word to fit their own categories. No doubt this kind of bible will have its appeal, but it will not be the Word of God. Just because liberals do this kind of translation does not justify its practice by political and economic conservatives.

Tuesday, August 4, 2009

Beware the leaven of the Republicans and other right wing voices

This blog is about theological thoughts. Theology speaks to everything since there is no "square inch of earth that Jesus Christ does not say, This is mine." (Abraham Kuyper).

Leaven is the biblical word for yeast and speaks to its effects in dough. Jesus used the word to warn his disciples about the Pharisees and others whose words and teachings were false and not according to God's word and will.

In our day we (Christians and everyone else) must beware of the leaven of the right wing who for the most part are Republicans. Their words are false and thus lead people to believe what amounts to lies as they put their particular spin on matters like health care reform, judicial nominations and the President's place of birth. Their actions are immoral for they violate God's condemnation of lying (the 9th commandment; Paul's words in Ephesians).

Their comments deliberately misconstrue the intent of health care reform, especially as it relates to end of life issues. They have riled up senior citizens with their message that the government will require senior citizens to prepare for euthenasia. This leads to uncivil and rude behavior at meetings where members of Congress and the Secretary of Health try to explain the plans for health care reform. Of course, senior citizens are responsible for their own behavior if they listen to the right wing without checking out the facts for themselves. Beware of the leaven of the right wing.

The leaven of the right wing appears in comments about Judge Sotomayor. Like zombies, most Republicans and their right wing supporters (handlers?) are opposing her nomination calling her a judicial activist. Have they forgotten to think for themselves? Beware of their leaven.

Beware of the leaven of the right wing when they question the qualifications of Barack Obama to be president based on his place of birth. In spite of evidence supporting his birth in Hawaii, they insist on demanding proof of his birth place.

Christians involved in the right wing need to repent and stop believing lies and other self-serving assertions. They need to be like the members of the synagogue in Berea and check out what they are told "to see if these things be so." They need to do their own research and not take the words of others with an agenda.

Tuesday, July 14, 2009

MC USA: To Laugh or to Cry?

I read today the new issue of Mennonite Weekly Review with coverage of the 2009 gathering of the Mennonite Church in the USA. As I read the articles on the gathering, I did not know whether to laugh or to cry. I was moved to prayer for the church. It seems rather clear that Mennonites have abandoned their long standing commitment to the Bible, at least in regard to the nature of the church. Gone is the sense of the church as a called out people not conformed to the world. Instead, in the name of inclusivity everything goes. People and congregations may believe whatever they want without fear of church discipline. There is a fear of offending or excluding anyone.

The articles boasted of the presence of the Spirit at the gathering. Yet the actions of the gathering cannot be reconciled with the Biblical teaching of the Spirit. It is even likely that will the attendees boasted of the Spirit, that in actuality Ichabod has been written over the church.

The Mennonite convention in many ways parallels the General Convention of the Episcopal Church taking place now. In violation of Scripture, the Convention seems bent on approving blessings for same sex relationships. This is claimed to be the leading of the Spirit but that seems far fetched.

Eventually members from these churches will stand before Christ to give an account of their actions.

Saturday, May 2, 2009

Christians and the Right Wing

A prayer request at choir practice the other night prompts this post. A choir member asked prayer because the Department of Homeland Security supposedly has targeted American veterans and Christians. Doubting that this person had actually read this report, and because I believe in reading primary sources, I found the report online. Though it is no longer on the DHS website, a Google search will locate it.

In searching for the report I noticed all kinds of wild reactions to it, mostly critical. However, I was not surprised when I read the report. Rather than being wild and guilty of the criticisms by Christians and other conservatives, I found the report to be very measured and carefully written. It does not accuse American military veterans of anything. It does not accuse Christians of anything. It does take note of right wing extremist groups in the country. It carefully defines rightwing extremism as "those movements, and adherents that are primarily hate-oriented (based on hatred of particular religious, racial or ethnic groups) and those that are mainly antigovernment, rejecting federal authority in favor of state or local authority or rejecting government authority entirely." This may include "groups and individuals that are dedicated to a single issue, such as opposition to abortion or immigration."

The fact that some Christians and conservative commentators find the report troubling indicates that they have not read the report carefully or do not know how to read with comprehension. Their reactions to this report are totally uncalled for. The reactions of members of Congress are also uncalled for. Who cannot admit to the presence of extreme right wing groups in this country that fit the definition in the report? The report notes their existence, identifies some of their activities, notes how some military veterans have been drawn to these groups, and wonders if this could be a pattern for the present and future. American military veterans are no more pure and above board than any one else. The report does not paint every veteran with tar (I certainly don't feel tarred). It just expresses concern that some of them could be drawn in. Christians are not specifically named in the report. But we all know the actions of some opponents of abortion. If all Christians feel condemned by that, they need to ask themselves, why.

Christians who spread negative comments about this report without reading it are guilty of breaking the commandment against bearing false witness and not speaking the truth. They are also guilty of listening to others without reading and thinking about the matter. There is no excuse in this day and age for not locating the report and reading it for themselves. Talk show hosts and advocacy groups all have agendas. To listen to them but not to read the document in question is plain stupid and results in the kind of misinformation that one reads on the internet.

Saturday, April 18, 2009

Preaching the Resurrection

I heard three Easter sermons this week, one in person and the other two electonically. Of the three two were a bit disappointing. Rather than talking about the significance of Christ's resurrection, they made us the center of the story. Why is that? Are we tired of proclaiming the work of Christ in his resurrection? Are they afraid of intellectualizing the event? Or have they bought into the "me" culture of American Christianity where what an event means to me is more important than the objective nature of the event?

The resurrection of Jesus is an historical event. It's primary meaning is the message of Jesus' victory over death. The resurrection is a theological event and statement about Jesus. As the Apostle Paul says in I Corinthians 1, "we preach Christ crucified." Paul also said "we do not preach ourselves." To preach or emphasize our own experience is not the preaching of Christ. To preach Christ is not merely to talk about the Resurrected Lord but to preach the resurrection. How can we do less than the Apostles?

Of course, the resurrection has much to do with us. It is the guarantee of our resurrection, it is the basis of the whole Christian life. Those who believe in Christ and trust in his saving work are already resurrected to new life. But we can only talk about that in the context of preaching Christ's resurrection.

Wednesday, April 8, 2009

Something Like a Defense of Definitive Sanctification

In a recent post on his blog here Professor Scott Clark from Westminster Seminary in California critiques Professor John Murray's view of Definitive Sanctification. All three of these confessions are clear that Christ "is made unto us...sanctification," that those who are justified are also sanctified, and those that are "called and regenerated" are "further sanctified, really and personally, through the virtue of Christ's death and resurrection."

2. The absence of this doctrine in Reformed theology is not necessarily a sign of error. Reformed theologians are human and finite. Their perspective has limitations especially as they developed their views vis-a-vis the views of Rome. Reformed theologians and confessions were more concerned with issues of justification and good works and the relationship between the two.

3. Reformed theology missed an opportunity to develop its views of sanctification as compared to the Roman view which treated justification and sanctification together. An understanding of Definitive Sanctification would have made clear the difference between justification and sanctification and yet understood both as the work of Christ.

4. In Paul, sanctification is parallel to justification and glorification. If justification is a definitive act, there is no reason not to believe that sanctification and glorification are not likewise definitive. In justification, God declares us righteous. In Christ we are glorified, having been seated in the heavenly places (Colossians 3) already. In sanctification, God declares us to be holy, to belong to him, to be set apart for his service. We do not become more justified nor more glorified. We are sanctified which is the whole basis for the imperatives of the Christian life in Paul's letters.

Thinking along these lines, Murray's concept is Reformed.

Saturday, March 28, 2009

Holy Scripture (5)

A much fuller exposition of the Quaker doctrine of the Scriptures is given by Robert Barclay in his 1673 work A Catechism and Confession of Faith. Chapter II bears the title "Of the Rule and Guide of Christians and of the Scriptures." Barclay treats the distinction between the Old and New Covenants in a way that exalts their dis-unity over against unity. His emphasis is rather on the role of the Spirit as the guide and rule of Christians under the Gospel. He makes much of the teaching ministry of the Holy Spirit. Thus, in answer to the question "Is it an inward principle, then that is to be the guide and rule of Christians?" he quotes I John 2:27 and I Thessalonians 4:9 as affirmative answers. This naturally raises the question about the purpose of Scripture. To answer that he refers to Romans 15:4-it was given to comfort and strengthen us. It does not, however, lead us to the truth; this the work of the Holy Spirit.

We have previously mentioned Barclay's other writing An Apology for the True Christian Divinity. This work consists of 15 propositions and an exposition of each. Proposition III deals with the Quaker doctrine of Scripture, and refutes other options. Barclay describes Scripture as having proceeded from the Spirit of God and containing (1) "a faithful historical account of the actings of God's people in divers ages," (2) a prophetical account of things which have to come to pass and things yet to occur, and (3) "a full and ample account of all the chief principles of the doctrines of Christ." (Barclay, An Apology for the True Christian Divinity, 72-73). The Scriptures are not, however, "the adequate primary rule of faith and manners" (73). The Spirit is the principle rule; Scripture is secondary to the Spirit.

Sunday, March 15, 2009

The Second London Baptist Confession of 1677/1689

Since I haven't posted for a while, I wanted to share my understanding of the differences between the Westminster Confession of Faith and the London Baptist Confession of 1689. As I wrote in my WTS Th.M. thesis, I believe that the differences between the two confessions (aside from the obvious differences related to Baptist ecclesiology) are due to a difference theological climate in Great Britain. By 1677, the Baptists were dealing with a different set of theological issues than the divines of Westminster in 1647. This is true, too, regarding the differences between the first London Baptist Confession of 1644 and the second confession. The writers of the 1677 confession made a clear decision to use the Westminster Confession as a model. Yet, they made a variety of changes in wording which I believe are due to the presence of more radical groups such as the Quakers, and the rise of rationalism in religion, especially as that affected doctrines related to Holy Scripture and the Trinity. The 1677 confession's teaching on Holy Scripture seems to be dealing with both the views of Quakers and the views of rationalism as applied to Scripture. With this in mind, I will continue now with more of my Th.M. thesis.

What was the Quaker doctrine of Scripture? To answer this question we may examine the views of two Quakers--James Nayler and Robet Barclay. Nayler was an early associate of George Fox. In January, 1653, he was placed on trial in Appleby, England. The following conversation was part of that trial:

Just[ice] Pears[on]: "To the Word: What sayest thou to the Scriptures? are they the Word of God?"

Jam[es] Nayler: They are a true declaration of the word that was in them who spoke them forth."

Higginson: Is there not a written Word?"

Jam[es] Nayler: Where readest thou in the Scriptures of a written Word? The word is spiritual, not seen with carnal eyes: but as for the Scriptures they are trie, and I witness them true, in measure fulfilled in me, as far as i am grown up." (Hugh Barbour and Arthur O. Roberts, eds., Early Quaker Writings 1650-1700) (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1973), pp. 261-262.)

Nayler also reveals his view of the Scriptures in response to Richard Baxter's The Quaker Catechism of 1655 (Baxter's replies to Quaker questions are in Barbour and Roberts, Early Quaker Writings, p. 273). Nayler refers to Baxter's position that the Scriptures were written to be a standing rule. His response is to mock it. wondering how this could be when "scarce two of you can agree about it, what is the meaing of it, and how many copies is there of it? Which of them is the standing rule? (Barbour and Roberts, Early Quaker Writings, 284.) He then responded to some queries put forth by Baxter: Do they believe the Scriptures to be true? Nayler answers in the affirmative, but responds negatively to Baxter's position that the Scriptures call themselves the Word of God. Baxter, says, Nayler, did not bring forth any Biblical texts to prove that "the letter is the word." (Barbour and Roberts, Early Quaker Writings, 284).

Wednesday, February 18, 2009

Holy Scripture (4)

The other approach that Hill notes is one that denies the infallibility of the Bible, and subjects it to textual criticism (Hill, 261-263). What Hill calls the denial of infallibility, he illustrates with examples which may be classified as denials of authority and examples of supposed errors.

Against such a background the emphasis of the Second London Confession may be seen the best. We may isolate one particular group that the writers of the Confession may have had in mind when they affirmed the "Scripture is the only sufficient, certain,and infallible rule of all saving Knowledge, Faith, and Obedience." This group is most likely the Quakers. This is not an arbitrary identification. It s based on an understanding of the events of mid-17th century English church history. Though we will not be able to spell out the full scope of their often stormy relationship (Lumpkin, Baptist Confessions of Faith, demonstrates how several Baptist confessions were directed specifically at the Quakers), we can discuss some of the doctrinal and practical points at which Baptists and Quakers were engaged in conflict.

Saturday, February 7, 2009

Holy Scripture (3)

It must be remembered that the Baptists wrote their confession nearly thirty years after the Westminster Confession was written. Much had happened in England in the intervening years. The Baptists faced doctrinal problems not faced in the mid-1640s. This was especially true concerning the Scriptures. The Baptist emphasis on the sufficiency and infallibility of Scripture was probably written to refute erros about the nature of Scripture circulating in mid-17th century England.

Christopher Hill has summarized the attitude toward the Scriptures by radical groups in England in terms of two main approaches. One approach was to "use its stories as myths to which each could give his own sense, a sense that need not consider the original meaning of the text." (Christopher Hill, The World Turned Upside Down (Middlesex: Penguin Books, 1975), 261). Such a use was illustrated in the writings of the Quaker apologist Robert Barclay. Writing in 1675, Barclay described the work of the Scriptures, their service to us, as a mirror in which we see the experiences of the saints of old. Through this we are strengthened and confirmed and given the hope of obtaining the same end. Scripture is something to be fulfilled in us. As Scripture is fulfilled in us, we "discern the stamp of God's spirit and ways upon them." (Robert Barclay, An Apology for the True Christian Divinity being an Explanation and Vindication of the Principles and Doctrines of the people called Quakers (Philadelphia: Friends Book Store, n.d.), 88).

Wednesday, January 21, 2009

Second London Confession: Holy Scripture (2)

This is not to say that the Westminster Confession does not use the term "infallible," for it does, as a hermeneutical approach to Scripture. "The infallible rule of interpretation of Scripture is the Scripture itself (WCF I.9). The Second London Confession says the same thing. However, when comparing the two confessions, the Second London Confession uses infallibility to describe the character of Scripture. Thus the confession opens with these words: The Holy Scripture is the only sufficient, certain, and infallibile rule of all saving Knowledge, Faith, and Obedience (SLC I.1).

The reason for the Baptist affirmation of the infallibility of Scripture has nothing to do with an attempt to show doctrinal superiority over the Westminster Confession, but rather to address contemporary matters in English theology.