Showing posts with label American Christianity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label American Christianity. Show all posts

Friday, February 19, 2010

Dual Citizens

In his book, Dual Citizens, pastor Jason Stellman attempts to set forth his understanding of how the Bible describes what is known in Reformed and other circles as how believers are to live during the period of the “already/not yet.” This refers to the period between Christ’s first and second comings. Herman Ridderbos is one of the best known presenters of this idea, which he has done in his books The Coming of the Kingdom and Paul: An Outline of his Theology. According to Ridderbos (and others), Jesus’ birth, life, death and resurrection inaugurated the presence of God’s kingdom. Believers in Jesus receive the benefits of that kingdom: forgiveness, release from sin, new life and hope. Beyond that, this concept means that God’s rule has already begun in the life of Jesus. This is the “already.” The “not yet” refers to the future consummation of that kingdom.
Pastor Stellman’s purpose in his book is to develop the implications of the already/not yet for Christian life. This is a worthy task. It deals with the essence of our lives as we await Christ’s return. Having read the book, I have some concerns about his underlying presuppositions and how he constructs his approach. My concerns are with his separation of worship and life (what he calls cult and culture), his understanding of covenant theology and his caricatures of evangelical and Christian spiritual disciplines.
Since his separation of worship and life is based on his understanding of God’s covenant(s), I will begin there. An essential element of a Reformed understanding of God’s covenants is their unity. The various covenants are part of God’s overall covenantal approach and dealing with people in general and his people in particular. O. Palmer Robertson, in his Christ of the Covenants, devotes a whole chapter to the unity of God’s covenants, particularly the covenants with Noah, Abraham, Moses and David. These covenants build on the one before them and culminate in the New Covenant inaugurated by Jesus. This Reformed understanding is contrasted with a dispensational view which does not see the covenants as a unity and posits a difference between Israel and the Church.
Pastor Stellman’s approach to the covenants seems to be more dispensational than Reformed. I say this because he posits the need for a specific geographic location as important to how God’s covenants impact the way God’s people live. Under the covenants with Adam and Moses, God had initiated a theocracy which governed every aspect of life, including cult and culture. In regard to the covenant with Moses, it was especially in effect as long as Israel was in the land given them by God. When Israel was in exile in Babylon, the stipulations of the covenant governing Israel’s relationships with others did not apply. Once Israel returned to the land under Ezra and Nehemiah, all the stipulations of the covenant were once again in effect.
In regard to the conduct of believers during the period between Christ’s first and second comings, Pastor Stellman asserts that the church, like Israel in Babylon, is in exile. In this exilic state, it is possible to separate worship from the rest of life. He specifically rejects John Frame’s assertion that it is “difficult to separate “life” from “worship” in a biblical framework.” As Pastor Stellman writes, when they [God’s people] are exiles and pilgrims, they are called to separate themselves only religiously, not culturally.” This approach seems problematical. It seems to undercut the unity of the covenants. It also seems contrary to the realities of the New Covenant and Christ’s Lordship.
Under the New Covenant, the Church is called “a chosen people, a royal priesthood, a holy nation, a people belonging to God…” (I Peter 2:9 NIV). Paul says in Philippians 4:20, “our citizenship is in heaven…” He also tells us in Romans 12:2 to not be conformed to the world. Peter gives the same advice in I Peter 2:11-12.
The Church’s designation as a holy people and nation relates the Church to Israel. Yet, the Church is not in exile. The Church’s presence in the world is not punishment for disobedience, but for the purpose of declaring the glory of the one who brought them from darkness to life. Under the New Covenant, the church has no specific dedicated piece of land like Israel did in Canaan. All the earth belongs to the Lord (Ps. 24). Under the New Covenant, the possession of a specific piece of geography is not essential to the covenant since all the earth is the Lord’s. Thus, Pastor Stellman’s view of a separation between worship and life is without foundation. Christians are in the world to witness and they are called to be salt and light, separate from and not conforming to the world around them.
In this regard, Christians come in contact with the world around them. Like Israel, there are restrictions on how the Church interacts with the world. Christians are not to marry outside the faith (I Cor. 7:39). Believers are not to be yoked with unbelievers (2 Cor. 8:14-18). Christians are not to take each other to court (I Cor. 6). Christians were to take responsibility for each other, especially widows, orphans and any one else in need.
His book is clear about the differences between the church and the world and he makes some valuable evaluations of how the church operates in American culture. Christians in the United States must be open to suffering, be less demanding of prestige and power. Yet, in his evaluation of American evangelicalism, Pastor Stellman caricatures some spiritual disciplines that many American Christians, including this writer, find meaningful. These disciplines include a daily quiet time, listening to Christian music and retreats. He refers to these as “extra-canonical sacraments,” and hints that they are a gnostic form of spirituality (a charge that Mike Horton makes in Christless Christianity). He also implies that these practices stand in contrast to Reformed confessional understandings of Christian living, though without referring to specific confessional content. This Reformed confessional understanding centers on the local congregation where God’s Word is preached each Sunday.
Here he sets up a false dichotomy, and shows some personal bias toward American evangelicals. According to him (in Chapter 7), American evangelicals would rather practice personal individual piety than attend a local church where the Word of God is preached. Perhaps that is true in some cases, but the reality is that evangelical Christians probably attend church more than they practice individual disciplines. For me (and no doubt for many others) the discipline of a daily quiet time does not rule out attendance at a local congregation. The two practices complement each other. The practice of a daily quiet time is not to receive special revelation (as in Gnosticism) to “read, mark, learn and inwardly digest” the Scriptures, to meditate on them and to engage in daily prayer. Corporate worship is important, but it does not rule out individual worship.
In another area, he is critical of the desire of evangelicals for application in the sermons they hear. This, he says, is a desire for law not gospel. I wonder what he does with the letters of the Apostle Paul. Many of Paul’s letters can be divided into two parts: the indicative (what God has done in Christ) and the imperative (the application of the indicative). Much evangelical preaching probably is more application or “practical” and less oriented toward declaring what God has done in Christ. But the desire for application means that Christians take seriously what it means to be a Christian and how we live out our faith in the world. This would be similar to those aspects of the Law that defined how Israel was to live in a pagan environment. Given the state of American Christianity, as evangelicals like Ron Side and Jim Wallis have pointed out, American Christians need more application to know how to live as God’s holy people in the midst of a pagan society.
American Christians (as do all Christians) live as dual citizens of two worlds. Yet the Head of the Church is the Lord of the nations. Our allegiance is to one Lord. But, as Paul says in Philippians 4:20, our citizenship is in heaven. It is from the consummation of the kingdom that we are exiles and pilgrims. It is the values of God’s kingdom that are to guide us during our pilgrimage.

Thursday, November 26, 2009

Christless Christianity, part 3

The final comments about Horton's Christless Christianity have to do with the charge of Gnosticism in American Christianity and Horton's use of secondary sources to argue his position in the book.

I have a hard time identifying American Christianity with the Gnostics of the early church era. I am not convinced by his arguments that this is true. To make this argument, Horton depends on the work of Harold Bloom, especially his work The American Religion. Here, Bloom sees Gnostics under every rock. His own Gnosticism becomes the lens through which he interprets American Christianity. However, Bloom's work has been criticized by Martin Marty and Alfred Kazin. They say that the charge of Gnosticism might stick if applied only to non-Christian American religion and the search for spirituality. Bloom, however, tries to make it stick to Christianity in the United States. The Gnosticism he sees appears in the private aspects of Protestantism. He especially takes a shot at the Baptist idea of "soul competency." As defined by Baptists, this means "the God-given freedom and ability of persons to know and respond to God’s will. Baptists believe that God gives people competency--that is ability--to make choices. Human beings are not puppets or machines." There is nothing particulary Gnostic about this.

It seems that Horton has used Bloom's work and the work of Harold Lee (who agrees with Bloom) rather uncritically. It is this uncritical use of secondary sources which bothers me about his book. Rather than do his own investigation of the use and place of Christ in American preaching, he relies on the work of other people, not to illustrate his own research, but in place of it.

Horton's book would have been better if he concentrated on Joel Osteen and the prosperity gospel movement and done so with his own analysis.

Saturday, November 7, 2009

Christless Christianity

The recent discussion in the blogosphere over John Frame's review of Michael Horton's book Christless Christianity (http://www.frame-poythress.org/frame_articles/2009Horton.htm) has led me to buy a copy of Professor Horton's book to read for myself. I finished the book a few days ago, but today is the first chance I've had to post my own comments. This entry will focus on Horton's book. I will evaluate John Frame's response in another post.

In general, I found the work to be uneven. Chapters 6 and 7 are well written and thought out. The arguments are clear, concise and cogent. The work of Christ is clearly spelled out in Chapter 6 and a call to faithfulness is well presented in Chapter 7.

The earlier chapters, however, seemed to me to have been written in a rush. There is a sense of passion in his arguments, which is not wrong in and of itself, but makes these chapters less well thought out than the closing chapters. I found myself making a number of comments about what he was saying. I will return to these chapters below.

Second, I think a better subtitle such as A Critique of Joel Osteen and the Prosperity Gospel would have been preferable. This is where the meat of Horton's argument is directed and would have saved him from Frame's criticism of painting with a broad brush.

Third, Horton is right in describing some parts of evangelicalism (to say nothing of liberalism) as vacuous. I have worshiped in some churches where the prayers and the sermon really said nothing useful. He is also correct in identifying a particular kind of American Christianity. In this regard, he could have strengthened his case by refering to the work of Mark Noll in his book America's God which clearly describes an American theology that has been shaped by American ideals. For instance, on page 54 Horton says, "It is not secular humanists but we ourselves who are secularizing the faith by transforming its odd message in some less jarring to the American psyche." This is precisely the point Noll makes in his work.

I will now review the first three chapters of Christless Christianity as well as chapter 5.

In chapter one, Horton describes what he means by Christless Christianity. It is that Christ is not preached in the apostolic sense. Instead, Jesus is a prop "for our own play." Sermons address issues like marriage, spiritual disciplines. Some of what Horton writes is similar to Ed Clowney's test of a Christian sermon: If a rabbi could preach that sermon, it wasn't Christian.

Yet, Horton's argument in chapter 1 is not totally convincing. He does not paint a clear picture of what he really means by a Christless Christianity. The closest he comes is his oft repeated phrase, "Do more, try harder." While this may be true, he says this is what he assumes "to be the regular diet in many churches across America..." (p. 17). He does not say at this point what grounds he has for that assumption. It is almost like he is setting up a straw man to knock down. As his discussions in the book later show, however, he is not setting up a straw man. If he had introduced some of that evidence in this first chapter, his arguments would be on firmer ground.

At the end of the chapter, Horton acknowledges that his judgments may be too sweeping or ill-informed. He further claims not to have any "particular wing, movement, person, or group" in mind. Further reading in the book reveals, however, that he does have particular persons in mind. Aside from that, he does make judgments that are too sweeping.

Chapter 2 is dedicated to naming the American captivity, which he calls "moralistic, therapeutic deism." Part of his arguments in this chapter are anecdotes, part based on the research of George Barna, Christian Smith, James Davison Hunter and other researchers, as well as magazine articles and even television dialogue. The closest Horton comes to dealing with primary sources is when he analyzes the preaching of Charles Finney. Yet, there is a difference between the Arminian, Semi-Pelagian preaching of Finney and the preaching recorded by Barna and others. He is right that some of Finney's preaching could be called moralistic, but it is a stretch to call it therapeutic and deistic.

Horton's sources in this chapter are one problem for me. Using secondary sources may be a time saving device, but in the age of the Internet, he could have searched for sermons online to evaluate and draw his own conclusions.

A second problem for me in this chapter is the structure. On page 48 he notes the work of Marcha Witten who analyzed a number of sermons regarding the prodigal son preached by Southern Baptist and PCUSA pastors. Yet, it is not until page 55 that he more or less begins to deal with the results of her work. The intervening pages are a side trip in which he again discusses the problem he sees with some parts of American Christianity. When he begins to discuss her findings, he does so uncritically. Witten found that the sermons treated God as the extravagent lover. Horton seems to accept this conclusion. Yet, is this not the point of the parable, especially as described by Tim Keller in his book The Prodigal God? Horton laments the absence of any need of a mediator or Christ's atoning work. He seems to have forgotten that this is a parable and must be understood as such. Witten found (and Horton accepts) that the preachers had a variety of things to say about the younger son and critiques the pastors for what they said and did not say. Some of their comments about the younger son are moralistic and perhaps do not take seriously enough his actions. But the parable is about God and is meant for the Pharisees. Neither Witten or Horton seem to get this.

More later.