Showing posts with label Westminster Confession of Faith. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Westminster Confession of Faith. Show all posts

Wednesday, January 21, 2009

Second London Confession: Holy Scripture (2)

This is not to say that the Westminster Confession does not use the term "infallible," for it does, as a hermeneutical approach to Scripture. "The infallible rule of interpretation of Scripture is the Scripture itself (WCF I.9). The Second London Confession says the same thing. However, when comparing the two confessions, the Second London Confession uses infallibility to describe the character of Scripture. Thus the confession opens with these words: The Holy Scripture is the only sufficient, certain, and infallibile rule of all saving Knowledge, Faith, and Obedience (SLC I.1).

The reason for the Baptist affirmation of the infallibility of Scripture has nothing to do with an attempt to show doctrinal superiority over the Westminster Confession, but rather to address contemporary matters in English theology.

Wednesday, January 14, 2009

Second London Baptist Confession: Holy Scripture

The most obvious difference between the Westminster and the Second London Confession is found in the opening sentence of the Second London Confession: The Holy Scripture is the only sufficient, certain, and the infallible rule of all saving Knowledge, faith, and Obedience. In the Westminster standards, this concept is not explicitly discussed. However, if the question is not raised outright, it is implied in the Westminster standards. Following Calvin's views, the Westminster Confession contrasts God's revelation in nature and creation, with his revelation in Scripture (WCF I.1). Natural, creation revelation is not "sufficient to give that knowledge of God, and of His will which is necessary unto salvation." God, therefore, gave the Scriptures "to declare...His will unto His church" and to better preserve and propagate the truth. Scripture is thus a better means of God's revelation. It is sufficient to give the knowledge of God and His will that leads to salvation. If it is sufficient, it is at least by implication, trustworthy, which is an acceptable synonym for "infallible."

Sunday, January 11, 2009

The London Baptist Confession of 1689 and the Westminster Confession of Faith

For my Th.M. thesis at Westminster Seminary in Philadelphia, I wrote a comparison of the London Baptist Confession of 1677/1689 and the Westminster Confession of Faith of 1646. At the heart of the thesis was a harmony of the two confessions, laboriously typed on a portable typewriter by my wife. The thesis explored the differences between the confessions as suggested by the harmony. The point of the thesis was to argue that the Second London Confession was a confession in its own right, and not just a Baptist recension of the Westminster Confession as Philip Schaff suggested. I will be trying, as time and energy permit, to publish in this blog the material from my thesis that supports this argument.

Wednesday, August 13, 2008

Peter Enns on WHYY

I'm listening to Marty Moss-Coane interview Peter Enns today. So far he has declared that "our tradition" "the Reformed tradition" does not hold that God is the sole author of Scripture. I wonder what he has been reading. I am reading B.B. Warfield's essay on the doctrine of Scripture in the Westminster Confession; he seems pretty clear that God is the sole author of Scripture. Gaffin's recent book on Kuyper and Bavinck's views of Scripture concludes pretty much the same thing. The Reformed tradition, at least as I learned it at WTS in the late 1970s holds that God is the author of Scripture. That belief does not negate the role of Moses, David, the prophets, Paul, John, Peter and those responsible for Kings and Chronicles. It seems to me that PE's tradition is not the tradition of Machen, Young and other Reformed biblical scholars.

Tuesday, April 8, 2008

Confessional is not narrow

Having reread the posts on many blogs about Westminster and Peter Enns, I want to say that I would find it hard to call WTS "narrow-minded" as many have done. In my student days, our biblical studies profs had different approaches to the Bible, but all within the seminary's commitment to the Westminster Standards and the seminary's own commitment to the inspiration, infallibility and authority of Scripture. Even the Confession does not expressly state that Scripture is infallible and inerrant, it does hold a very high view of Scripture. The Confession says nothing about the way Scripture was inspired or how the canon was formed. I have heard Dr. Gaffin talk about canonicity one way, and Dr. Dillard describe it another way. Both are within the bounds of the Confession.

However, to begin to talk about Peter Enns, to question the evangelical doctrine of the inspiration of Scripture (as he does in Inspiration and Incarnation) is not a very Westminster-like thing to do.