A prayer request at choir practice the other night prompts this post. A choir member asked prayer because the Department of Homeland Security supposedly has targeted American veterans and Christians. Doubting that this person had actually read this report, and because I believe in reading primary sources, I found the report online. Though it is no longer on the DHS website, a Google search will locate it.
In searching for the report I noticed all kinds of wild reactions to it, mostly critical. However, I was not surprised when I read the report. Rather than being wild and guilty of the criticisms by Christians and other conservatives, I found the report to be very measured and carefully written. It does not accuse American military veterans of anything. It does not accuse Christians of anything. It does take note of right wing extremist groups in the country. It carefully defines rightwing extremism as "those movements, and adherents that are primarily hate-oriented (based on hatred of particular religious, racial or ethnic groups) and those that are mainly antigovernment, rejecting federal authority in favor of state or local authority or rejecting government authority entirely." This may include "groups and individuals that are dedicated to a single issue, such as opposition to abortion or immigration."
The fact that some Christians and conservative commentators find the report troubling indicates that they have not read the report carefully or do not know how to read with comprehension. Their reactions to this report are totally uncalled for. The reactions of members of Congress are also uncalled for. Who cannot admit to the presence of extreme right wing groups in this country that fit the definition in the report? The report notes their existence, identifies some of their activities, notes how some military veterans have been drawn to these groups, and wonders if this could be a pattern for the present and future. American military veterans are no more pure and above board than any one else. The report does not paint every veteran with tar (I certainly don't feel tarred). It just expresses concern that some of them could be drawn in. Christians are not specifically named in the report. But we all know the actions of some opponents of abortion. If all Christians feel condemned by that, they need to ask themselves, why.
Christians who spread negative comments about this report without reading it are guilty of breaking the commandment against bearing false witness and not speaking the truth. They are also guilty of listening to others without reading and thinking about the matter. There is no excuse in this day and age for not locating the report and reading it for themselves. Talk show hosts and advocacy groups all have agendas. To listen to them but not to read the document in question is plain stupid and results in the kind of misinformation that one reads on the internet.
Saturday, May 2, 2009
Saturday, April 18, 2009
Preaching the Resurrection
I heard three Easter sermons this week, one in person and the other two electonically. Of the three two were a bit disappointing. Rather than talking about the significance of Christ's resurrection, they made us the center of the story. Why is that? Are we tired of proclaiming the work of Christ in his resurrection? Are they afraid of intellectualizing the event? Or have they bought into the "me" culture of American Christianity where what an event means to me is more important than the objective nature of the event?
The resurrection of Jesus is an historical event. It's primary meaning is the message of Jesus' victory over death. The resurrection is a theological event and statement about Jesus. As the Apostle Paul says in I Corinthians 1, "we preach Christ crucified." Paul also said "we do not preach ourselves." To preach or emphasize our own experience is not the preaching of Christ. To preach Christ is not merely to talk about the Resurrected Lord but to preach the resurrection. How can we do less than the Apostles?
Of course, the resurrection has much to do with us. It is the guarantee of our resurrection, it is the basis of the whole Christian life. Those who believe in Christ and trust in his saving work are already resurrected to new life. But we can only talk about that in the context of preaching Christ's resurrection.
The resurrection of Jesus is an historical event. It's primary meaning is the message of Jesus' victory over death. The resurrection is a theological event and statement about Jesus. As the Apostle Paul says in I Corinthians 1, "we preach Christ crucified." Paul also said "we do not preach ourselves." To preach or emphasize our own experience is not the preaching of Christ. To preach Christ is not merely to talk about the Resurrected Lord but to preach the resurrection. How can we do less than the Apostles?
Of course, the resurrection has much to do with us. It is the guarantee of our resurrection, it is the basis of the whole Christian life. Those who believe in Christ and trust in his saving work are already resurrected to new life. But we can only talk about that in the context of preaching Christ's resurrection.
Labels:
Apostle Paul,
Easter,
Jesus Christ,
preaching,
resurrection
Wednesday, April 8, 2009
Something Like a Defense of Definitive Sanctification
In a recent post on his blog here Professor Scott Clark from Westminster Seminary in California critiques Professor John Murray's view of Definitive Sanctification. All three of these confessions are clear that Christ "is made unto us...sanctification," that those who are justified are also sanctified, and those that are "called and regenerated" are "further sanctified, really and personally, through the virtue of Christ's death and resurrection."
2. The absence of this doctrine in Reformed theology is not necessarily a sign of error. Reformed theologians are human and finite. Their perspective has limitations especially as they developed their views vis-a-vis the views of Rome. Reformed theologians and confessions were more concerned with issues of justification and good works and the relationship between the two.
3. Reformed theology missed an opportunity to develop its views of sanctification as compared to the Roman view which treated justification and sanctification together. An understanding of Definitive Sanctification would have made clear the difference between justification and sanctification and yet understood both as the work of Christ.
4. In Paul, sanctification is parallel to justification and glorification. If justification is a definitive act, there is no reason not to believe that sanctification and glorification are not likewise definitive. In justification, God declares us righteous. In Christ we are glorified, having been seated in the heavenly places (Colossians 3) already. In sanctification, God declares us to be holy, to belong to him, to be set apart for his service. We do not become more justified nor more glorified. We are sanctified which is the whole basis for the imperatives of the Christian life in Paul's letters.
Thinking along these lines, Murray's concept is Reformed.
2. The absence of this doctrine in Reformed theology is not necessarily a sign of error. Reformed theologians are human and finite. Their perspective has limitations especially as they developed their views vis-a-vis the views of Rome. Reformed theologians and confessions were more concerned with issues of justification and good works and the relationship between the two.
3. Reformed theology missed an opportunity to develop its views of sanctification as compared to the Roman view which treated justification and sanctification together. An understanding of Definitive Sanctification would have made clear the difference between justification and sanctification and yet understood both as the work of Christ.
4. In Paul, sanctification is parallel to justification and glorification. If justification is a definitive act, there is no reason not to believe that sanctification and glorification are not likewise definitive. In justification, God declares us righteous. In Christ we are glorified, having been seated in the heavenly places (Colossians 3) already. In sanctification, God declares us to be holy, to belong to him, to be set apart for his service. We do not become more justified nor more glorified. We are sanctified which is the whole basis for the imperatives of the Christian life in Paul's letters.
Thinking along these lines, Murray's concept is Reformed.
Saturday, March 28, 2009
Holy Scripture (5)
A much fuller exposition of the Quaker doctrine of the Scriptures is given by Robert Barclay in his 1673 work A Catechism and Confession of Faith. Chapter II bears the title "Of the Rule and Guide of Christians and of the Scriptures." Barclay treats the distinction between the Old and New Covenants in a way that exalts their dis-unity over against unity. His emphasis is rather on the role of the Spirit as the guide and rule of Christians under the Gospel. He makes much of the teaching ministry of the Holy Spirit. Thus, in answer to the question "Is it an inward principle, then that is to be the guide and rule of Christians?" he quotes I John 2:27 and I Thessalonians 4:9 as affirmative answers. This naturally raises the question about the purpose of Scripture. To answer that he refers to Romans 15:4-it was given to comfort and strengthen us. It does not, however, lead us to the truth; this the work of the Holy Spirit.
We have previously mentioned Barclay's other writing An Apology for the True Christian Divinity. This work consists of 15 propositions and an exposition of each. Proposition III deals with the Quaker doctrine of Scripture, and refutes other options. Barclay describes Scripture as having proceeded from the Spirit of God and containing (1) "a faithful historical account of the actings of God's people in divers ages," (2) a prophetical account of things which have to come to pass and things yet to occur, and (3) "a full and ample account of all the chief principles of the doctrines of Christ." (Barclay, An Apology for the True Christian Divinity, 72-73). The Scriptures are not, however, "the adequate primary rule of faith and manners" (73). The Spirit is the principle rule; Scripture is secondary to the Spirit.
We have previously mentioned Barclay's other writing An Apology for the True Christian Divinity. This work consists of 15 propositions and an exposition of each. Proposition III deals with the Quaker doctrine of Scripture, and refutes other options. Barclay describes Scripture as having proceeded from the Spirit of God and containing (1) "a faithful historical account of the actings of God's people in divers ages," (2) a prophetical account of things which have to come to pass and things yet to occur, and (3) "a full and ample account of all the chief principles of the doctrines of Christ." (Barclay, An Apology for the True Christian Divinity, 72-73). The Scriptures are not, however, "the adequate primary rule of faith and manners" (73). The Spirit is the principle rule; Scripture is secondary to the Spirit.
Sunday, March 15, 2009
The Second London Baptist Confession of 1677/1689
Since I haven't posted for a while, I wanted to share my understanding of the differences between the Westminster Confession of Faith and the London Baptist Confession of 1689. As I wrote in my WTS Th.M. thesis, I believe that the differences between the two confessions (aside from the obvious differences related to Baptist ecclesiology) are due to a difference theological climate in Great Britain. By 1677, the Baptists were dealing with a different set of theological issues than the divines of Westminster in 1647. This is true, too, regarding the differences between the first London Baptist Confession of 1644 and the second confession. The writers of the 1677 confession made a clear decision to use the Westminster Confession as a model. Yet, they made a variety of changes in wording which I believe are due to the presence of more radical groups such as the Quakers, and the rise of rationalism in religion, especially as that affected doctrines related to Holy Scripture and the Trinity. The 1677 confession's teaching on Holy Scripture seems to be dealing with both the views of Quakers and the views of rationalism as applied to Scripture. With this in mind, I will continue now with more of my Th.M. thesis.
What was the Quaker doctrine of Scripture? To answer this question we may examine the views of two Quakers--James Nayler and Robet Barclay. Nayler was an early associate of George Fox. In January, 1653, he was placed on trial in Appleby, England. The following conversation was part of that trial:
Just[ice] Pears[on]: "To the Word: What sayest thou to the Scriptures? are they the Word of God?"
Jam[es] Nayler: They are a true declaration of the word that was in them who spoke them forth."
Higginson: Is there not a written Word?"
Jam[es] Nayler: Where readest thou in the Scriptures of a written Word? The word is spiritual, not seen with carnal eyes: but as for the Scriptures they are trie, and I witness them true, in measure fulfilled in me, as far as i am grown up." (Hugh Barbour and Arthur O. Roberts, eds., Early Quaker Writings 1650-1700) (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1973), pp. 261-262.)
Nayler also reveals his view of the Scriptures in response to Richard Baxter's The Quaker Catechism of 1655 (Baxter's replies to Quaker questions are in Barbour and Roberts, Early Quaker Writings, p. 273). Nayler refers to Baxter's position that the Scriptures were written to be a standing rule. His response is to mock it. wondering how this could be when "scarce two of you can agree about it, what is the meaing of it, and how many copies is there of it? Which of them is the standing rule? (Barbour and Roberts, Early Quaker Writings, 284.) He then responded to some queries put forth by Baxter: Do they believe the Scriptures to be true? Nayler answers in the affirmative, but responds negatively to Baxter's position that the Scriptures call themselves the Word of God. Baxter, says, Nayler, did not bring forth any Biblical texts to prove that "the letter is the word." (Barbour and Roberts, Early Quaker Writings, 284).
What was the Quaker doctrine of Scripture? To answer this question we may examine the views of two Quakers--James Nayler and Robet Barclay. Nayler was an early associate of George Fox. In January, 1653, he was placed on trial in Appleby, England. The following conversation was part of that trial:
Just[ice] Pears[on]: "To the Word: What sayest thou to the Scriptures? are they the Word of God?"
Jam[es] Nayler: They are a true declaration of the word that was in them who spoke them forth."
Higginson: Is there not a written Word?"
Jam[es] Nayler: Where readest thou in the Scriptures of a written Word? The word is spiritual, not seen with carnal eyes: but as for the Scriptures they are trie, and I witness them true, in measure fulfilled in me, as far as i am grown up." (Hugh Barbour and Arthur O. Roberts, eds., Early Quaker Writings 1650-1700) (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1973), pp. 261-262.)
Nayler also reveals his view of the Scriptures in response to Richard Baxter's The Quaker Catechism of 1655 (Baxter's replies to Quaker questions are in Barbour and Roberts, Early Quaker Writings, p. 273). Nayler refers to Baxter's position that the Scriptures were written to be a standing rule. His response is to mock it. wondering how this could be when "scarce two of you can agree about it, what is the meaing of it, and how many copies is there of it? Which of them is the standing rule? (Barbour and Roberts, Early Quaker Writings, 284.) He then responded to some queries put forth by Baxter: Do they believe the Scriptures to be true? Nayler answers in the affirmative, but responds negatively to Baxter's position that the Scriptures call themselves the Word of God. Baxter, says, Nayler, did not bring forth any Biblical texts to prove that "the letter is the word." (Barbour and Roberts, Early Quaker Writings, 284).
Wednesday, February 18, 2009
Holy Scripture (4)
The other approach that Hill notes is one that denies the infallibility of the Bible, and subjects it to textual criticism (Hill, 261-263). What Hill calls the denial of infallibility, he illustrates with examples which may be classified as denials of authority and examples of supposed errors.
Against such a background the emphasis of the Second London Confession may be seen the best. We may isolate one particular group that the writers of the Confession may have had in mind when they affirmed the "Scripture is the only sufficient, certain,and infallible rule of all saving Knowledge, Faith, and Obedience." This group is most likely the Quakers. This is not an arbitrary identification. It s based on an understanding of the events of mid-17th century English church history. Though we will not be able to spell out the full scope of their often stormy relationship (Lumpkin, Baptist Confessions of Faith, demonstrates how several Baptist confessions were directed specifically at the Quakers), we can discuss some of the doctrinal and practical points at which Baptists and Quakers were engaged in conflict.
Against such a background the emphasis of the Second London Confession may be seen the best. We may isolate one particular group that the writers of the Confession may have had in mind when they affirmed the "Scripture is the only sufficient, certain,and infallible rule of all saving Knowledge, Faith, and Obedience." This group is most likely the Quakers. This is not an arbitrary identification. It s based on an understanding of the events of mid-17th century English church history. Though we will not be able to spell out the full scope of their often stormy relationship (Lumpkin, Baptist Confessions of Faith, demonstrates how several Baptist confessions were directed specifically at the Quakers), we can discuss some of the doctrinal and practical points at which Baptists and Quakers were engaged in conflict.
Saturday, February 7, 2009
Holy Scripture (3)
It must be remembered that the Baptists wrote their confession nearly thirty years after the Westminster Confession was written. Much had happened in England in the intervening years. The Baptists faced doctrinal problems not faced in the mid-1640s. This was especially true concerning the Scriptures. The Baptist emphasis on the sufficiency and infallibility of Scripture was probably written to refute erros about the nature of Scripture circulating in mid-17th century England.
Christopher Hill has summarized the attitude toward the Scriptures by radical groups in England in terms of two main approaches. One approach was to "use its stories as myths to which each could give his own sense, a sense that need not consider the original meaning of the text." (Christopher Hill, The World Turned Upside Down (Middlesex: Penguin Books, 1975), 261). Such a use was illustrated in the writings of the Quaker apologist Robert Barclay. Writing in 1675, Barclay described the work of the Scriptures, their service to us, as a mirror in which we see the experiences of the saints of old. Through this we are strengthened and confirmed and given the hope of obtaining the same end. Scripture is something to be fulfilled in us. As Scripture is fulfilled in us, we "discern the stamp of God's spirit and ways upon them." (Robert Barclay, An Apology for the True Christian Divinity being an Explanation and Vindication of the Principles and Doctrines of the people called Quakers (Philadelphia: Friends Book Store, n.d.), 88).
Christopher Hill has summarized the attitude toward the Scriptures by radical groups in England in terms of two main approaches. One approach was to "use its stories as myths to which each could give his own sense, a sense that need not consider the original meaning of the text." (Christopher Hill, The World Turned Upside Down (Middlesex: Penguin Books, 1975), 261). Such a use was illustrated in the writings of the Quaker apologist Robert Barclay. Writing in 1675, Barclay described the work of the Scriptures, their service to us, as a mirror in which we see the experiences of the saints of old. Through this we are strengthened and confirmed and given the hope of obtaining the same end. Scripture is something to be fulfilled in us. As Scripture is fulfilled in us, we "discern the stamp of God's spirit and ways upon them." (Robert Barclay, An Apology for the True Christian Divinity being an Explanation and Vindication of the Principles and Doctrines of the people called Quakers (Philadelphia: Friends Book Store, n.d.), 88).
Labels:
Hermeneutics,
Holy Scripture,
Particular Baptists,
Quakers
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)