Thursday, November 26, 2009

Christless Christianity, part 3

The final comments about Horton's Christless Christianity have to do with the charge of Gnosticism in American Christianity and Horton's use of secondary sources to argue his position in the book.

I have a hard time identifying American Christianity with the Gnostics of the early church era. I am not convinced by his arguments that this is true. To make this argument, Horton depends on the work of Harold Bloom, especially his work The American Religion. Here, Bloom sees Gnostics under every rock. His own Gnosticism becomes the lens through which he interprets American Christianity. However, Bloom's work has been criticized by Martin Marty and Alfred Kazin. They say that the charge of Gnosticism might stick if applied only to non-Christian American religion and the search for spirituality. Bloom, however, tries to make it stick to Christianity in the United States. The Gnosticism he sees appears in the private aspects of Protestantism. He especially takes a shot at the Baptist idea of "soul competency." As defined by Baptists, this means "the God-given freedom and ability of persons to know and respond to God’s will. Baptists believe that God gives people competency--that is ability--to make choices. Human beings are not puppets or machines." There is nothing particulary Gnostic about this.

It seems that Horton has used Bloom's work and the work of Harold Lee (who agrees with Bloom) rather uncritically. It is this uncritical use of secondary sources which bothers me about his book. Rather than do his own investigation of the use and place of Christ in American preaching, he relies on the work of other people, not to illustrate his own research, but in place of it.

Horton's book would have been better if he concentrated on Joel Osteen and the prosperity gospel movement and done so with his own analysis.

Monday, November 9, 2009

Christless Christianity, Part 2

In chapter 3 of Christless Christianity, Mike Horton analyzes the ministry of Joel Osteen and others like him. This is one of the most passionate chapters in the book. Osteen's ministry becomes the paradigm to analyze popular religion in the United States. Horton's analysis of Osteen can be summarized in the phrase facere quod in se est (do your best) from medieval theology. Osteen even seems to think that God will "make it up" in regard to difference between God's expectations and our efforts. Osteen may not be a theologian, but he seems to have grasped the essentials of medieval Christian theology.

A curious aspect of Horton's analysis is his statement (which he admits sounds heretical), "it is probably worth telling Americans that you don't need Jesus to have better families, finances, health, or even morality." I think Horton is saying that this is the gist of most American preaching. Christians as well as most Americans do not need to believe in Jesus to have all the good things of life. However, for those of us who live in the already/not yet period between the resurrection and Christ's return, having Jesus is no guarantee of any of these blessings. Indeed, following Christ can mean family divisions, poverty, illness and death.

Turning to chapter 4 (How we turn good news into good advice), Horton uses the law-gospel distinction to analyze modern religion. His discussion raises a couple questions. One concerns his assertion that we are not to live the gospel, but only believe it. He resists the idea of living the gospel because he thinks that makes it a message about us. I think Paul would disagree. He wrote in 2 Corinthians 3:2, "You yourselves are our letter of recommendation, written on our hearts, to be known and read by all. And you show that you are a letter from Christ, delievered by us, written not with ink, but with the Spirit of the living God, not on tablets of stone but on tablets of human hearts" (ESV). Paul seems to be saying that the Corinthians were living gospels because of the work of God's Spirit in them. Paul also wrote to the Ephesians, Therefore be imitators of God, as beloved children. And walk in love as Christ loved us and gave himself up for us, a fragrant offering and sacrifice to God" (5:1-2) (ESV). Again, Paul seems to say that imitating Christ is not law, but gospel. Paul gives practical advice, instruction and calls to discipleship which may be considered as gospel because they grow out of our justification and salvation in Christ.

A second question about law and gospel arises when Horton says we need "a fresh encounter with God's law in its full force." The question is this: did Jesus and Paul preach the law? It seems that the answer must be, No, because they preached the good news of the kingdom. It must be said that Peter and Paul, when addressing the Jews, spoke about the Jewish rejection of Jesus and the judgment that would follow if they did not repent and believe in Jesus. Jesus preached "repent and believe the good news." The problem with American preaching may be that pastors do not know how to preach the gospel because they do not know how to preach Christ from the OT, and they do not know how to ground behavior in the work of Christ. Whenever pastors give good advice, instruct their hearers in the teachings of the Bible and call them to discipleship, they need to ground all that in the work of Christ which people are called to believe.

It is finally in this chapter that Horton tells us what he means by "Christless Christianity." In his words it

does not mean religion or spirituality devoid of the words Jesus, Christ, Lord or even
Saviour. What it means is the way those names and titles are employed will be
removed from their specific location in an unfolding historical plot of human rebellion
and divine rescue and from such practices as baptism and communion.

If he had put this in the first chapter and organized the book around this definition, this work would be more clear, cogent and concise.

More to follow.

Saturday, November 7, 2009

Christless Christianity

The recent discussion in the blogosphere over John Frame's review of Michael Horton's book Christless Christianity (http://www.frame-poythress.org/frame_articles/2009Horton.htm) has led me to buy a copy of Professor Horton's book to read for myself. I finished the book a few days ago, but today is the first chance I've had to post my own comments. This entry will focus on Horton's book. I will evaluate John Frame's response in another post.

In general, I found the work to be uneven. Chapters 6 and 7 are well written and thought out. The arguments are clear, concise and cogent. The work of Christ is clearly spelled out in Chapter 6 and a call to faithfulness is well presented in Chapter 7.

The earlier chapters, however, seemed to me to have been written in a rush. There is a sense of passion in his arguments, which is not wrong in and of itself, but makes these chapters less well thought out than the closing chapters. I found myself making a number of comments about what he was saying. I will return to these chapters below.

Second, I think a better subtitle such as A Critique of Joel Osteen and the Prosperity Gospel would have been preferable. This is where the meat of Horton's argument is directed and would have saved him from Frame's criticism of painting with a broad brush.

Third, Horton is right in describing some parts of evangelicalism (to say nothing of liberalism) as vacuous. I have worshiped in some churches where the prayers and the sermon really said nothing useful. He is also correct in identifying a particular kind of American Christianity. In this regard, he could have strengthened his case by refering to the work of Mark Noll in his book America's God which clearly describes an American theology that has been shaped by American ideals. For instance, on page 54 Horton says, "It is not secular humanists but we ourselves who are secularizing the faith by transforming its odd message in some less jarring to the American psyche." This is precisely the point Noll makes in his work.

I will now review the first three chapters of Christless Christianity as well as chapter 5.

In chapter one, Horton describes what he means by Christless Christianity. It is that Christ is not preached in the apostolic sense. Instead, Jesus is a prop "for our own play." Sermons address issues like marriage, spiritual disciplines. Some of what Horton writes is similar to Ed Clowney's test of a Christian sermon: If a rabbi could preach that sermon, it wasn't Christian.

Yet, Horton's argument in chapter 1 is not totally convincing. He does not paint a clear picture of what he really means by a Christless Christianity. The closest he comes is his oft repeated phrase, "Do more, try harder." While this may be true, he says this is what he assumes "to be the regular diet in many churches across America..." (p. 17). He does not say at this point what grounds he has for that assumption. It is almost like he is setting up a straw man to knock down. As his discussions in the book later show, however, he is not setting up a straw man. If he had introduced some of that evidence in this first chapter, his arguments would be on firmer ground.

At the end of the chapter, Horton acknowledges that his judgments may be too sweeping or ill-informed. He further claims not to have any "particular wing, movement, person, or group" in mind. Further reading in the book reveals, however, that he does have particular persons in mind. Aside from that, he does make judgments that are too sweeping.

Chapter 2 is dedicated to naming the American captivity, which he calls "moralistic, therapeutic deism." Part of his arguments in this chapter are anecdotes, part based on the research of George Barna, Christian Smith, James Davison Hunter and other researchers, as well as magazine articles and even television dialogue. The closest Horton comes to dealing with primary sources is when he analyzes the preaching of Charles Finney. Yet, there is a difference between the Arminian, Semi-Pelagian preaching of Finney and the preaching recorded by Barna and others. He is right that some of Finney's preaching could be called moralistic, but it is a stretch to call it therapeutic and deistic.

Horton's sources in this chapter are one problem for me. Using secondary sources may be a time saving device, but in the age of the Internet, he could have searched for sermons online to evaluate and draw his own conclusions.

A second problem for me in this chapter is the structure. On page 48 he notes the work of Marcha Witten who analyzed a number of sermons regarding the prodigal son preached by Southern Baptist and PCUSA pastors. Yet, it is not until page 55 that he more or less begins to deal with the results of her work. The intervening pages are a side trip in which he again discusses the problem he sees with some parts of American Christianity. When he begins to discuss her findings, he does so uncritically. Witten found that the sermons treated God as the extravagent lover. Horton seems to accept this conclusion. Yet, is this not the point of the parable, especially as described by Tim Keller in his book The Prodigal God? Horton laments the absence of any need of a mediator or Christ's atoning work. He seems to have forgotten that this is a parable and must be understood as such. Witten found (and Horton accepts) that the preachers had a variety of things to say about the younger son and critiques the pastors for what they said and did not say. Some of their comments about the younger son are moralistic and perhaps do not take seriously enough his actions. But the parable is about God and is meant for the Pharisees. Neither Witten or Horton seem to get this.

More later.

Wednesday, October 21, 2009

Anglicans and Rome

For the life of me, I cannot understand why any Anglican/Episcopalian would accept the invitation of the Bishop of Rome to return to the Roman Catholic Church. Granted, the Catholic Church of today is not the church of the days of Henry VIII. Yet, Roman Catholic teaching on important articles of faith are at variance with the teachings of the 39 Articles and the English Reformers.

Those from the Anglican community who are open to the Bishop of Rome's invitation seem to do so for two reasons: Roman Catholic moral teaching which has not given in to the moral relativism found in the Episcopal Church; and to be seen to be ecumenical. However, they are overlooking fundamental differences between the two churches regarding the basics of salvation. The 39 Articles and the English reformers, e.g., Archbishop Cranmer, teach a decidedly Protestant and Reformed view of justification by faith. The Catholic Church continues to hold to unreformed views of justification.

The 39 Articles position on justification is clear:

XI. Of the Justification of Man.We are accounted righteous before God, only for the merit of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ by Faith, and not for our own works or deservings. Wherefore, that we are justified by Faith only, is a most wholesome Doctrine, and very full of comfort, as more largely is expressed in the Homily of Justification.

Compare this to the teaching of the Catechism of the Catholic Church of 1992:

1992 Justification has been merited for us by the Passion of Christ who offered himself on the cross as a living victim, holy and pleasing to God, and whose blood has become the instrument of atonement for the sins of all men. Justification is conferred in Baptism, the sacrament of faith. It conforms us to the righteousness of God, who makes us inwardly just by the power of his mercy. Its purpose is the glory of God and of Christ, and the gift of eternal life:[40] But now the righteousness of God has been manifested apart from law, although the law and the prophets bear witness to it, the righteousness of God through faith in Jesus Christ for all who believe. For there is no distinction: since all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God, they are justified by his grace as a gift, through the redemption which is in Christ Jesus, whom God put forward as an expiation by his blood, to be received by faith. This was to show God's righteousness, because in his divine forbearance he had passed over former sins; it was to prove at the present time that he himself is righteous and that he justifies him who has faith in Jesus.[41]

1990 Justification detaches man from sin which contradicts the love of God, and purifies his heart of sin. Justification follows upon God's merciful initiative of offering forgiveness. It reconciles man with God. It frees from the enslavement to sin, and it heals.

2008 The merit of man before God in the Christian life arises from the fact that God has freely chosen to associate man with the work of his grace. The fatherly action of God is first on his own initiative, and then follows man's free acting through his collaboration, so that the merit of good works is to be attributed in the first place to the grace of God, then to the faithful. Man's merit, moreover, itself is due to God, for his good actions proceed in Christ, from the predispositions and assistance given by the Holy Spirit.

2019 Justification includes the remission of sins, sanctification, and the renewal of the inner man.

While there are similarities between the two statements, but the Catholic statement puts more emphasis on human merit and action to the point of collaboration with God. The Catholic view of justification combines justification into one, rather than keeping them separate as reformation theology does.

For this and other reasons, Anglicans should be wary about returning to Rome. Rome has not reformed itself enough to warrant the return of anyone from Canterbury.

Tuesday, October 6, 2009

A Conservative Bible??

It is not enough to make god in our image. News on the Internet today heralds the planning of a "conservative" Bible, i.e., a Bible that reflects the language and concepts of political and economic conservatives. http://www.conservapedia.com/Conservative_Bible_Project claims that the Bible as translated now is too liberal. By liberal they mean:
  • a framework of liberal bias. This includes the presence of John 8:53ff (the woman taken in adultery), the inclusion of verses not found in the best manuscripts, socialism (as evidenced by terms like comrade) and questioning the use of "shrewdly" in regard to the dishonest manager in the Gospels.
  • not emasculated, a reference to the unisex of the NIV and other translations.
  • not dumbing down the language of Scripture in translations. They complain that the NIV is written for a 7th grade reading level. This begs the question of how difficult the language of Scripture should be. Since the NT was written in koine Greek, which was the common language of the people, it seems right to translate the NT into a language which its readers can understand. Martin Luther recognized this when he produced a Bible in German for common people to read.
  • using language that hides addictions. Their example here is "casting lots" instead of gambling. However, the Roman soldiers were not gambling when they cast lots for Jesus' clothing. Casting lots was a common practice in the ancient world and in the Bible.
  • not understanding the free market language of Jesus' parables. Jesus's parables were not economic lessons, but lessons about the kingdom of God.
  • being wordy.
  • not translating Word (logos) in John 1:1 by the word truth.

This project only makes sense as another way in which people reject the revelation of God. Rather than being challenged and transformed by God's inerrant and infallible Word, this project seeks to judge God's Word to fit their own categories. No doubt this kind of bible will have its appeal, but it will not be the Word of God. Just because liberals do this kind of translation does not justify its practice by political and economic conservatives.

Tuesday, August 4, 2009

Beware the leaven of the Republicans and other right wing voices

This blog is about theological thoughts. Theology speaks to everything since there is no "square inch of earth that Jesus Christ does not say, This is mine." (Abraham Kuyper).

Leaven is the biblical word for yeast and speaks to its effects in dough. Jesus used the word to warn his disciples about the Pharisees and others whose words and teachings were false and not according to God's word and will.

In our day we (Christians and everyone else) must beware of the leaven of the right wing who for the most part are Republicans. Their words are false and thus lead people to believe what amounts to lies as they put their particular spin on matters like health care reform, judicial nominations and the President's place of birth. Their actions are immoral for they violate God's condemnation of lying (the 9th commandment; Paul's words in Ephesians).

Their comments deliberately misconstrue the intent of health care reform, especially as it relates to end of life issues. They have riled up senior citizens with their message that the government will require senior citizens to prepare for euthenasia. This leads to uncivil and rude behavior at meetings where members of Congress and the Secretary of Health try to explain the plans for health care reform. Of course, senior citizens are responsible for their own behavior if they listen to the right wing without checking out the facts for themselves. Beware of the leaven of the right wing.

The leaven of the right wing appears in comments about Judge Sotomayor. Like zombies, most Republicans and their right wing supporters (handlers?) are opposing her nomination calling her a judicial activist. Have they forgotten to think for themselves? Beware of their leaven.

Beware of the leaven of the right wing when they question the qualifications of Barack Obama to be president based on his place of birth. In spite of evidence supporting his birth in Hawaii, they insist on demanding proof of his birth place.

Christians involved in the right wing need to repent and stop believing lies and other self-serving assertions. They need to be like the members of the synagogue in Berea and check out what they are told "to see if these things be so." They need to do their own research and not take the words of others with an agenda.

Tuesday, July 14, 2009

MC USA: To Laugh or to Cry?

I read today the new issue of Mennonite Weekly Review with coverage of the 2009 gathering of the Mennonite Church in the USA. As I read the articles on the gathering, I did not know whether to laugh or to cry. I was moved to prayer for the church. It seems rather clear that Mennonites have abandoned their long standing commitment to the Bible, at least in regard to the nature of the church. Gone is the sense of the church as a called out people not conformed to the world. Instead, in the name of inclusivity everything goes. People and congregations may believe whatever they want without fear of church discipline. There is a fear of offending or excluding anyone.

The articles boasted of the presence of the Spirit at the gathering. Yet the actions of the gathering cannot be reconciled with the Biblical teaching of the Spirit. It is even likely that will the attendees boasted of the Spirit, that in actuality Ichabod has been written over the church.

The Mennonite convention in many ways parallels the General Convention of the Episcopal Church taking place now. In violation of Scripture, the Convention seems bent on approving blessings for same sex relationships. This is claimed to be the leading of the Spirit but that seems far fetched.

Eventually members from these churches will stand before Christ to give an account of their actions.