The other approach that Hill notes is one that denies the infallibility of the Bible, and subjects it to textual criticism (Hill, 261-263). What Hill calls the denial of infallibility, he illustrates with examples which may be classified as denials of authority and examples of supposed errors.
Against such a background the emphasis of the Second London Confession may be seen the best. We may isolate one particular group that the writers of the Confession may have had in mind when they affirmed the "Scripture is the only sufficient, certain,and infallible rule of all saving Knowledge, Faith, and Obedience." This group is most likely the Quakers. This is not an arbitrary identification. It s based on an understanding of the events of mid-17th century English church history. Though we will not be able to spell out the full scope of their often stormy relationship (Lumpkin, Baptist Confessions of Faith, demonstrates how several Baptist confessions were directed specifically at the Quakers), we can discuss some of the doctrinal and practical points at which Baptists and Quakers were engaged in conflict.
Wednesday, February 18, 2009
Saturday, February 7, 2009
Holy Scripture (3)
It must be remembered that the Baptists wrote their confession nearly thirty years after the Westminster Confession was written. Much had happened in England in the intervening years. The Baptists faced doctrinal problems not faced in the mid-1640s. This was especially true concerning the Scriptures. The Baptist emphasis on the sufficiency and infallibility of Scripture was probably written to refute erros about the nature of Scripture circulating in mid-17th century England.
Christopher Hill has summarized the attitude toward the Scriptures by radical groups in England in terms of two main approaches. One approach was to "use its stories as myths to which each could give his own sense, a sense that need not consider the original meaning of the text." (Christopher Hill, The World Turned Upside Down (Middlesex: Penguin Books, 1975), 261). Such a use was illustrated in the writings of the Quaker apologist Robert Barclay. Writing in 1675, Barclay described the work of the Scriptures, their service to us, as a mirror in which we see the experiences of the saints of old. Through this we are strengthened and confirmed and given the hope of obtaining the same end. Scripture is something to be fulfilled in us. As Scripture is fulfilled in us, we "discern the stamp of God's spirit and ways upon them." (Robert Barclay, An Apology for the True Christian Divinity being an Explanation and Vindication of the Principles and Doctrines of the people called Quakers (Philadelphia: Friends Book Store, n.d.), 88).
Christopher Hill has summarized the attitude toward the Scriptures by radical groups in England in terms of two main approaches. One approach was to "use its stories as myths to which each could give his own sense, a sense that need not consider the original meaning of the text." (Christopher Hill, The World Turned Upside Down (Middlesex: Penguin Books, 1975), 261). Such a use was illustrated in the writings of the Quaker apologist Robert Barclay. Writing in 1675, Barclay described the work of the Scriptures, their service to us, as a mirror in which we see the experiences of the saints of old. Through this we are strengthened and confirmed and given the hope of obtaining the same end. Scripture is something to be fulfilled in us. As Scripture is fulfilled in us, we "discern the stamp of God's spirit and ways upon them." (Robert Barclay, An Apology for the True Christian Divinity being an Explanation and Vindication of the Principles and Doctrines of the people called Quakers (Philadelphia: Friends Book Store, n.d.), 88).
Labels:
Hermeneutics,
Holy Scripture,
Particular Baptists,
Quakers
Wednesday, January 21, 2009
Second London Confession: Holy Scripture (2)
This is not to say that the Westminster Confession does not use the term "infallible," for it does, as a hermeneutical approach to Scripture. "The infallible rule of interpretation of Scripture is the Scripture itself (WCF I.9). The Second London Confession says the same thing. However, when comparing the two confessions, the Second London Confession uses infallibility to describe the character of Scripture. Thus the confession opens with these words: The Holy Scripture is the only sufficient, certain, and infallibile rule of all saving Knowledge, Faith, and Obedience (SLC I.1).
The reason for the Baptist affirmation of the infallibility of Scripture has nothing to do with an attempt to show doctrinal superiority over the Westminster Confession, but rather to address contemporary matters in English theology.
The reason for the Baptist affirmation of the infallibility of Scripture has nothing to do with an attempt to show doctrinal superiority over the Westminster Confession, but rather to address contemporary matters in English theology.
Wednesday, January 14, 2009
Second London Baptist Confession: Holy Scripture
The most obvious difference between the Westminster and the Second London Confession is found in the opening sentence of the Second London Confession: The Holy Scripture is the only sufficient, certain, and the infallible rule of all saving Knowledge, faith, and Obedience. In the Westminster standards, this concept is not explicitly discussed. However, if the question is not raised outright, it is implied in the Westminster standards. Following Calvin's views, the Westminster Confession contrasts God's revelation in nature and creation, with his revelation in Scripture (WCF I.1). Natural, creation revelation is not "sufficient to give that knowledge of God, and of His will which is necessary unto salvation." God, therefore, gave the Scriptures "to declare...His will unto His church" and to better preserve and propagate the truth. Scripture is thus a better means of God's revelation. It is sufficient to give the knowledge of God and His will that leads to salvation. If it is sufficient, it is at least by implication, trustworthy, which is an acceptable synonym for "infallible."
Sunday, January 11, 2009
The London Baptist Confession of 1689 and the Westminster Confession of Faith
For my Th.M. thesis at Westminster Seminary in Philadelphia, I wrote a comparison of the London Baptist Confession of 1677/1689 and the Westminster Confession of Faith of 1646. At the heart of the thesis was a harmony of the two confessions, laboriously typed on a portable typewriter by my wife. The thesis explored the differences between the confessions as suggested by the harmony. The point of the thesis was to argue that the Second London Confession was a confession in its own right, and not just a Baptist recension of the Westminster Confession as Philip Schaff suggested. I will be trying, as time and energy permit, to publish in this blog the material from my thesis that supports this argument.
Sunday, December 21, 2008
Rick Warren and the Invocation
The flap over President-elect Obama's choice of Rick Warren to give the invocation at the inaugaration next month seems a bit overblown. Since when does one have to be politically correct to pray at a presidential inauguration? Since when is one's views of homosexuality the test of political correctness? Why do people assume that Warren's position on the matter will affect how he prays? Or whether God will hear him? If people are offended, it will be necessary for them to check their own prejudices. And prejudiced they are. Such prejudices imply that everyone must agree to some standard line set up by the ones with the prejudice. Are they afraid of views contrary to theirs? Is their position threatened? The First Amendment guarantees the right of free speech and free exercise of religion. So, what is the problem?
Labels:
Barack Obama,
First Amendment,
Homosexuality,
Prayer,
Prejudice,
Rick Warren
Wednesday, November 12, 2008
Christians, Idolatry and the Military
The preacher at our church this past Sunday spoke from Joshua 24. Joshua challenged Israel to either worship Jehovah or their idols. If they chose Jehovah, they had to put away the idols. For the sake of the sermon, he defined an idol as that which requires sacrifices, gives the illusion of control and can be used for our own ends. It is interesting to use these criteria and compare them to God. God does not require human sacrifices, which many idols of the day did. Indeed, God arranged the ultimate sacrifice, that of his own Son, to bear the weight of his judgement on sin and to make atonement for our sins. God offers real control, not just an illusion, for he is the Lord of history. Finally, God is not to be used for our own ends, even though some Christians think in that way.
Our preacher's illustrative idol for the sermon was personal financial security which he explained in terms of his criteria for an idol. Yet, since this was the Sunday closest to Veterans Day, we also honored those who currently serve in the military and those who had. This made me think of military service in terms of idolatry. For purposes of full disclosure, I served in the U.S. Army during Vietnam, though I did not go there.
Military service and militarism in general can be viewed as an idol using his three criteria. First, it requires sacrifice, especially human sacrifice. Think of the many who have died or become disabled or suffer PTSD and other emotional traumas because of their military service. Other sacrifices of relationships and finances are also required by this idol, money that could be spent on better uses. Second, militarism offers the illusion of control. The bigger the military, the more control we think we have. The American experience in Vietnam put the lie to that. Third, militarism is a tool for our country to get its own way, or so we think. How many times in American history have we used our military forces to serve some vested interests?
Since God forbids his people to worship idols, why do we worship at this idol? Why
Our preacher's illustrative idol for the sermon was personal financial security which he explained in terms of his criteria for an idol. Yet, since this was the Sunday closest to Veterans Day, we also honored those who currently serve in the military and those who had. This made me think of military service in terms of idolatry. For purposes of full disclosure, I served in the U.S. Army during Vietnam, though I did not go there.
Military service and militarism in general can be viewed as an idol using his three criteria. First, it requires sacrifice, especially human sacrifice. Think of the many who have died or become disabled or suffer PTSD and other emotional traumas because of their military service. Other sacrifices of relationships and finances are also required by this idol, money that could be spent on better uses. Second, militarism offers the illusion of control. The bigger the military, the more control we think we have. The American experience in Vietnam put the lie to that. Third, militarism is a tool for our country to get its own way, or so we think. How many times in American history have we used our military forces to serve some vested interests?
Since God forbids his people to worship idols, why do we worship at this idol? Why
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)